McDonald Paul W
Department of Health Studies and Gerontology, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, N2L 3G1, Canada.
Prev Chronic Dis. 2007 Apr;4(2):A26. Epub 2007 Mar 15.
The population impact of programs designed to develop healthy eating behaviors is limited by the number of people who use them. Most public health providers and researchers rely on purchased mass media, which can be expensive, on public service announcements, or clinic-based recruitment, which can have limited reach. Few studies offer assistance for selecting high-outreach and low-cost strategies to promote healthy eating programs. The purpose of this study was 1) to determine whether classified newspaper advertising is an effective and efficient method of recruiting participants into a healthy eating program and 2) to determine whether segmenting messages by transtheoretical stage of change would help engage individuals at all levels of motivation to change their eating behavior.
For 5 days in 1997, three advertisements corresponding to different stages of change were placed in a Canadian newspaper with a daily circulation of 75,000.
There were 282 eligible people who responded to newspaper advertisements, and the cost was Can $1.11 (U.S. $0.72) per recruit. This cost compares favorably with the cost efficiency of mass media, direct mail, and other common promotional methods. Message type was correlated with respondent's stage of change, and this correlation suggested that attempts to send different messages to different audience segments were successful.
Classified advertisements appear to be a highly cost-efficient method for recruiting a diverse range of participants into healthy eating programs and research about healthy eating.
旨在培养健康饮食行为的项目对人群的影响受到使用这些项目的人数限制。大多数公共卫生服务提供者和研究人员依赖购买大众媒体(成本可能很高)、公共服务公告或基于诊所的招募方式,但这些方式的覆盖面可能有限。很少有研究为选择高覆盖面和低成本的策略来推广健康饮食项目提供帮助。本研究的目的是:1)确定分类报纸广告是否是一种有效且高效的方法,用于招募参与者参加健康饮食项目;2)确定根据行为改变的跨理论阶段划分信息是否有助于吸引处于不同动机水平的个体改变他们的饮食行为。
1997年,连续5天在一份日发行量为75000份的加拿大报纸上刊登了三则对应不同改变阶段的广告。
有282名符合条件的人回应了报纸广告,招募成本为每位参与者1.11加元(0.72美元)。这一成本与大众媒体、直邮和其他常见促销方式的成本效益相比具有优势。信息类型与回应者的改变阶段相关,这种相关性表明针对不同受众群体发送不同信息的尝试是成功的。
分类广告似乎是一种成本效益很高的方法,可用于招募各类参与者参加健康饮食项目以及有关健康饮食的研究。