Eldahdah Lama T, Ormond Kelly E, Nassar Anwar H, Khalil Tayma, Zahed Laila F
Graduate Program in Genetic Counseling, Northwestern University, Chicago IL, USA.
Prenat Diagn. 2007 Jun;27(6):525-34. doi: 10.1002/pd.1721.
To better understand obstetrician experiences in Lebanon when disclosing abnormal amniocentesis results.
Structured interviews with 38 obstetricians identified as caregivers from the American University of Beirut Medical Center Cytogenetics Laboratory database of patients with abnormal amniocentesis results between 1999 and 2005.
Obstetricians were primarily male, Christian, and with an average of 14 years of experience. They reported doing most pre-amniocentesis counseling, including discussion of risk for common autosomal aneuplodies (95%), and procedure-related risk (95%). Obstetricians reported that 80% of patients at risk for aneuploidy underwent amniocentesis. The study population reported on 143 abnormal test results (124 autosomal abnormalities). When disclosing results, obstetricians reportedly discussed primarily physical and cognitive features of the diagnosis. They varied in levels of directiveness and comfort in providing information. Our records showed that 59% of pregnancies with sex chromosome abnormalities were terminated compared to 90% of those with autosomal aneuploidies; various reasons were proposed by obstetricians.
This study is among the few to assess prenatal diagnosis practices in the Middle East, with a focus on the role of the obstetrician. Given the influence of culture and social norms on prenatal decision-making, it remains important to understand the various impacts on clinical practice in many nations.
为了更好地了解黎巴嫩产科医生在披露羊膜穿刺术异常结果时的经历。
对38名产科医生进行结构化访谈,这些医生是从贝鲁特美国大学医学中心细胞遗传学实验室1999年至2005年间羊膜穿刺术结果异常患者数据库中确定的护理人员。
产科医生主要为男性、基督教徒,平均有14年工作经验。他们报告称进行了大多数羊膜穿刺术前咨询,包括讨论常见常染色体非整倍体的风险(95%)以及与操作相关的风险(95%)。产科医生报告称,80%有非整倍体风险的患者接受了羊膜穿刺术。研究人群报告了143例异常检测结果(124例常染色体异常)。在披露结果时,产科医生据报道主要讨论了诊断的身体和认知特征。他们在提供信息时的指导程度和舒适度各不相同。我们的记录显示,59%的性染色体异常妊娠被终止,而常染色体非整倍体妊娠的这一比例为90%;产科医生提出了各种原因。
本研究是少数评估中东地区产前诊断实践的研究之一,重点关注产科医生的作用。鉴于文化和社会规范对产前决策的影响,了解许多国家对临床实践的各种影响仍然很重要。