Thompson Sandra C, Green Stephanie K, Stirling E Jessamy, James Ross
Centre for International Health, Curtin University, PO Box U1987, Perth, WA 6845, Australia.
Sex Health. 2007 Mar;4(1):9-16. doi: 10.1071/sh06010.
To investigate the nature of, and trends in, Australian print media coverage of sexually transmissible infections (STI) in indigenous Australians.
Newspaper articles from January 1986 to June 2004 were downloaded from the Factiva database. Of 164 articles examined based on our search criteria, 100 were included for analysis. An assessment of the tone and content of each article was made by two reviewers, and data were entered and analysed using EpiInfo (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA) RESULTS: Most articles were serious (89%), matter of fact and information dense (50%) and critical of the subject of the article (44%). Of the articles that were emotive, 78% evoked a sense of shock or frustration. The stimulus for the article was government related in 65%; a purely academic opinion was presented in 82%; and only one viewpoint was presented in 73%. The papers publishing the greatest number of articles were The Sydney Morning Herald (31%) and The Age (18%). From 1996 there was an increase in the number of articles and improvements in the voice given to indigenous informants. This may reflect initiatives in journalism education and release of a protocol on how STI in indigenous communities should be reported.
Overall, the style of reporting was heavy, dry and critical, written in an academic style and failed to critically examine or challenge government initiatives. The potential for print media to educate the general public is poorly utilised. Further exploration of how sensitive indigenous issues can be presented to avoid stereotyping, stigma and nihilism, while initiating more effective action, is needed.
调查澳大利亚平面媒体对澳大利亚原住民性传播感染(STI)的报道性质及趋势。
从Factiva数据库下载1986年1月至2004年6月的报纸文章。根据我们的搜索标准审查的164篇文章中,100篇纳入分析。两名评审员对每篇文章的语气和内容进行评估,并使用EpiInfo(美国疾病控制与预防中心,佐治亚州亚特兰大)输入和分析数据。结果:大多数文章是严肃的(89%)、基于事实且信息丰富的(50%),并对文章主题持批评态度(44%)。在具有情感色彩的文章中,78%引发了震惊或沮丧感。文章的刺激因素与政府相关的占65%;呈现纯粹学术观点的占82%;仅呈现一种观点的占73%。发表文章数量最多的报纸是《悉尼先驱晨报》(31%)和《时代报》(18%)。从1996年起文章数量增加,给予原住民信息提供者的话语权也有所改善。这可能反映了新闻教育方面的举措以及关于如何报道原住民社区性传播感染的协议的发布。
总体而言,报道风格沉重、枯燥且批判性强,采用学术风格,未能对政府举措进行批判性审视或质疑。平面媒体教育公众的潜力未得到充分利用。需要进一步探索如何在避免刻板印象、污名化和虚无主义的同时,以更有效的行动来呈现敏感的原住民问题。