Burwen Dale R, La Voie Lawrence, Braun M Miles, Houck Peter, Ball Robert
Division of Epidemiology, Office of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, Food and Drug Administration, Rockville, MD 20852, USA.
Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2007 Jul;16(7):753-61. doi: 10.1002/pds.1390.
Post-licensure observational studies using large linked databases can provide important data about whether adverse events are associated with vaccines, but databases that have been used may not have sufficient statistical power to examine rare events, and may underrepresent the elderly. We assessed the utility of Medicare data for evaluating adverse events after influenza and pneumococcal vaccines, by using an example involving selected clinical conditions, and evaluating aspects of data quality relevant to vaccine safety analyses.
We used 2001 data from the National Claims History File and Enrollment Database to determine if hospitalization for urinary tract infection (not likely associated with vaccination) or for cellulitis and abscess of the upper arm and forearm is associated with vaccination.
For influenza vaccine, the 7-day period after vaccination did not demonstrate an elevation in hospitalization with cellulitis and abscess of the upper arm and forearm; for pneumococcal vaccine, a clear peak was evident. No increase in urinary tract infection was found after either influenza or pneumococcal vaccine. Having a prior Medicare claim for pneumococcal vaccine within 5 years was a risk factor for hospitalization with cellulitis and abscess of the upper arm and forearm (relative risk, 2.6; 95% confidence limits (CL), 1.3, 5.0).
Medicare data are a useful source for evaluating adverse events after vaccination. Screening analyses can be performed using administrative data, but medical record review to validate diagnoses will often be needed for rigorous study of vaccine-adverse event associations.
利用大型关联数据库开展的上市后观察性研究能够提供有关不良事件是否与疫苗相关的重要数据,但已使用的数据库可能没有足够的统计效力来检验罕见事件,而且可能未充分纳入老年人。我们通过一个涉及特定临床病症的例子,并评估与疫苗安全性分析相关的数据质量方面,来评估医疗保险数据在评估流感和肺炎球菌疫苗接种后不良事件方面的效用。
我们使用了来自国家索赔历史文件和参保数据库的2001年数据,以确定因尿路感染(不太可能与疫苗接种相关)或上臂和前臂蜂窝织炎及脓肿住院是否与疫苗接种有关。
对于流感疫苗,接种后7天内,上臂和前臂蜂窝织炎及脓肿的住院率未升高;对于肺炎球菌疫苗,出现了明显的峰值。流感疫苗或肺炎球菌疫苗接种后均未发现尿路感染增加。在5年内曾有过肺炎球菌疫苗医疗保险索赔记录是上臂和前臂蜂窝织炎及脓肿住院的一个危险因素(相对风险为2.6;95%置信区间为1.3至5.0)。
医疗保险数据是评估疫苗接种后不良事件的有用来源。可以使用行政数据进行筛查分析,但对于疫苗不良事件关联的严谨研究,通常需要查阅病历以验证诊断。