Guzzetta Francesca, Tondo Leonardo, Centorrino Franca, Baldessarini Ross J
Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
J Clin Psychiatry. 2007 Mar;68(3):380-3. doi: 10.4088/jcp.v68n0304.
Evidence that clinical treatment reduces suicide risk in major depressive disorder (MDD) is limited and inconsistent. Since lithium shows major antisuicidal effects in bipolar disorders and in heterogeneous mood disorder samples, we evaluated evidence of antisuicidal effects of lithium in patients with recurrent MDD.
We searched MEDLINE (January 1966 to April 2006; search terms: lithium, suicide, affective disorder, depression, major depression, and mood disorder) for studies reporting suicides or suicide attempts during treatment with and without lithium in recurrent MDD patients, and we added data for 78 new subjects, provided from the Lucio Bini Mood Disorders Research Center in Sardinia, Italy. Suicide rates were pooled and analyzed by use of incidence-rate ratios (IRRs) and meta-analytic methods.
Eight studies involved 329 MDD patients and exposure for 4.56 years (1149 person-years) with, and 6.27 years (1285 person-years) without, lithium. Overall risk of suicides and suicide attempts was 88.5% lower with vs. without lithium: 0.17%/y versus 1.48%/y (IRR = 8.71; 95% CI: 2.10 to 77.2, p = .0005); for completed suicides (85% risk reduction), IRR = 6.77 (95% CI: 1.29 to 66.8, p = .01). Meta-analysis by risk difference and risk ratio supported these findings, and sensitivity analysis yielded similar results with studies omitted serially.
This is the first meta-analysis suggesting antisuicidal effects of lithium in recurrent MDD, similar in magnitude to that found in bipolar disorders.
临床治疗降低重度抑郁症(MDD)自杀风险的证据有限且不一致。鉴于锂盐在双相情感障碍和异质性心境障碍样本中显示出主要的抗自杀作用,我们评估了锂盐对复发性MDD患者抗自杀作用的证据。
我们检索了MEDLINE(1966年1月至2006年4月;检索词:锂盐、自杀、情感障碍、抑郁症、重度抑郁症和心境障碍),以查找有关复发性MDD患者在使用和未使用锂盐治疗期间自杀或自杀未遂情况的研究,并补充了意大利撒丁岛卢西奥·比尼心境障碍研究中心提供的78名新受试者的数据。采用发病率比(IRR)和荟萃分析方法汇总并分析自杀率。
八项研究涉及329例MDD患者,使用锂盐治疗的暴露时间为4.56年(1149人年),未使用锂盐治疗的暴露时间为6.27年(1285人年)。与未使用锂盐相比,使用锂盐时自杀和自杀未遂的总体风险降低了88.5%:分别为0.17%/年和1.48%/年(IRR = 8.71;95%CI:2.10至77.2,p = 0.0005);对于自杀死亡(风险降低85%),IRR = 6.77(95%CI:1.29至66.8,p = 0.01)。通过风险差和风险比进行的荟萃分析支持了这些发现,敏感性分析在逐一剔除研究后得出了相似的结果。
这是第一项荟萃分析,提示锂盐对复发性MDD有抗自杀作用,其程度与在双相情感障碍中发现的相似。