Taylor Stuart A, Slater Andrew, Burling David N, Tam Emily, Greenhalgh Rebecca, Gartner Louise, Scarth Julia, Pearce Robert, Bassett Paul, Halligan Steve
Department of Specialist Radiology, University College Hospital, Euston Road, London, UK.
Eur Radiol. 2008 Jan;18(1):32-42. doi: 10.1007/s00330-007-0631-0. Epub 2007 Apr 3.
To establish the optimum barium-based reduced-laxative tagging regimen prior to CT colonography (CTC). Ninety-five subjects underwent reduced-laxative (13 g senna/18 g magnesium citrate) CTC prior to same-day colonoscopy and were randomised to one of four tagging regimens using 20 ml 40%w/v barium sulphate: regimen A: four doses, B: three doses, C: three doses plus 220 ml 2.1% barium sulphate, or D: three doses plus 15 ml diatriazoate megluamine. Patient experience was assessed immediately after CTC and 1 week later. Two radiologists graded residual stool (1: none/scattered to 4: >50% circumference) and tagging efficacy for stool (1: untagged to 5: 100% tagged) and fluid (1: untagged, 2: layered, 3: tagged), noting the HU of tagged fluid. Preparation was good (76-94% segments graded 1), although best for regimen D (P = 0.02). Across all regimens, stool tagging quality was high (mean 3.7-4.5) and not significantly different among regimens. The HU of layered tagged fluid was higher for regimens C/D than A/B (P = 0.002). Detection of cancer (n = 2), polyps > or =6 mm (n = 21), and < or =5 mm (n = 72) was 100, 81 and 32% respectively, with only four false positives > or =6 mm. Reduced preparation was tolerated better than full endoscopic preparation by 61%. Reduced-laxative CTC with three doses of 20 ml 40% barium sulphate is as effective as more complex regimens, retaining adequate diagnostic accuracy.
在CT结肠成像(CTC)之前确定最佳的钡剂低剂量清肠标记方案。95名受试者在同一天进行结肠镜检查之前接受了低剂量清肠(13克番泻叶/18克枸橼酸镁)的CTC检查,并被随机分为使用20毫升40%w/v硫酸钡的四种标记方案之一:方案A:四剂;方案B:三剂;方案C:三剂加220毫升2.1%硫酸钡;或方案D:三剂加15毫升泛影葡胺。在CTC检查后立即和1周后评估患者的体验。两名放射科医生对残留粪便(1级:无/散在至4级:>50%周长)以及粪便(1级:未标记至5级:100%标记)和液体(1级:未标记,2级:分层,3级:标记)的标记效果进行分级,记录标记液体的HU值。尽管方案D的准备效果最佳(P = 0.02),但准备情况良好(76 - 94%的节段分级为1级)。在所有方案中,粪便标记质量都很高(平均3.7 - 4.5),各方案之间无显著差异。方案C/D分层标记液体的HU值高于方案A/B(P = 0.002)。癌症(n = 2)、≥6毫米的息肉(n = 21)和≤5毫米的息肉(n = 72)的检测率分别为100%、81%和32%,≥6毫米的假阳性仅4例。61%的患者对低剂量准备的耐受性优于全结肠镜检查准备。使用三剂20毫升40%硫酸钡的低剂量清肠CTC与更复杂的方案效果相同,保持了足够的诊断准确性。