Slotnick Burton, Sanguino Angelica, Husband Scott, Marquino Gregory, Silberberg Alan
Department of Psychology, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2007 Apr;117(4):743-9. doi: 10.1097/MLG.0b013e318033006b.
We assessed whether a nasal spray containing zinc gluconate (ZG) compromises the integrity of olfactory epithelium and olfactory function.
Axonal transport of horseradish peroxidase from olfactory epithelium to the olfactory bulb was studied in 2- to 21-day survival mice given intranasal injections of 2, 8, or 50 microL of ZG (approximately 4, 15, and 94 times the equivalent recommended human dose). Other similarly treated mice were tested using precision olfactometry to detect and discriminate odors.
Anatomic changes were graded as a function of dose and survival time. Two microliter injections had no discernable effect. while the 50 microL volume produced substantial deafferentation of input to the olfactory bulb in short-survival cases. Nearly complete restitution of input occurred within 3 weeks. At each volume and survival time, zinc sulfate (ZS) had a greater effect. Behaviorally, 2 microL and 8 microL ZG-treated mice and those given multiple injections of 2 microL ZG performed as well as controls, whereas those given 50 microL were hyposmic but not anosmic. ZS-treated mice performed more poorly, and those injected with 50 microL were anosmic for the first 8 to 10 test days.
A massive dose of a ZG nasal spray did cause a transient disruption of the olfactory epithelium and compromised olfaction. More moderate volumes, even those far in excess of a recommended dose, were largely without effect on odor detection and discrimination tasks. These outcomes fail to support the claims from recent clinical case reports that use of a ZG-containing nasal spray can produce anosmia.
我们评估了一种含葡萄糖酸锌(ZG)的鼻喷雾剂是否会损害嗅上皮的完整性和嗅觉功能。
在存活2至21天的小鼠中,通过鼻内注射2、8或50微升ZG(约为推荐人类等效剂量的4、15和94倍),研究辣根过氧化物酶从嗅上皮到嗅球的轴突运输。对其他经过类似处理的小鼠进行精确嗅觉测定,以检测和辨别气味。
解剖学变化根据剂量和存活时间进行分级。注射2微升没有明显影响,而在存活时间较短的情况下,注射50微升会导致大量传入嗅球的神经纤维脱失。在3周内输入几乎完全恢复。在每个剂量和存活时间下,硫酸锌(ZS)的影响更大。行为学上,注射2微升和8微升ZG的小鼠以及多次注射2微升ZG的小鼠表现与对照组一样好,而注射50微升的小鼠嗅觉减退但未嗅觉丧失。注射ZS的小鼠表现更差,注射50微升的小鼠在最初8至10个测试日嗅觉丧失。
大剂量的ZG鼻喷雾剂确实会导致嗅上皮的短暂破坏并损害嗅觉。更适度的剂量,即使远远超过推荐剂量,对气味检测和辨别任务大多没有影响。这些结果不支持近期临床病例报告中关于使用含ZG鼻喷雾剂会导致嗅觉丧失的说法。