Bhasin N, Scott D J A
Academic Unit of Molecular Vascular Medicine, The LIGHT Laboratories, University of Leeds, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2007 Apr;89(3):292-7. doi: 10.1308/003588407X155806.
BACKGROUND The Vascular Society of Great Britain and Ireland (VSGBI) annual meeting is a major international vascular surgery conference. Studies suggest that the percentage of presentations that result in full-text publications are a measure of the quality of the meeting. We investigated the publication outcome of abstracts presented to the VSGBI in 2001 and 2002. MATERIALS AND METHODS We retrospectively identified abstracts from the conference programmes and conducted a detailed electronic Medline and PubMed search to determine publication. We collected data regarding the study design, subject matter,publishing journal, time to publication, institution of origin, impact factors and RAE levels. RESULTS There were 63 publications from 106 abstracts (59.4%), with a median impact factor of 3.507. Prospective observational studies accounted for 20.6% of publications, with abdominal aortic aneurysms being the commonest subject matter(34.9%). The median time to publication was 12 months, with the European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery publishing 33.3% of the articles. Leicester achieved the highest number of publications and the majority of work came from centres with Research Assessment Exercise (RAE) level scores of 4, university centres accounted for 74.6% of publications. CONCLUSIONS We conclude that when compared to equivalent meetings in other specialties and geographical regions, the annual meeting of the VSGBI is of the very highest quality.
背景 大不列颠及爱尔兰血管外科学会(VSGBI)年会是一个重要的国际血管外科会议。研究表明,最终形成全文发表的报告所占百分比是衡量会议质量的一个指标。我们调查了2001年和2002年在VSGBI上发表的摘要的出版情况。
材料与方法 我们回顾性地从会议议程中识别出摘要,并进行了详细的电子Medline和PubMed检索以确定发表情况。我们收集了有关研究设计、主题、发表期刊、发表时间、来源机构、影响因子和研究评估卓越框架(RAE)等级的数据。
结果 106篇摘要中有63篇发表(59.4%),中位影响因子为3.507。前瞻性观察性研究占发表文章的20.6%,腹主动脉瘤是最常见的主题(34.9%)。中位发表时间为12个月,《欧洲血管与腔内血管外科学杂志》发表了33.3%的文章。莱斯特的发表数量最多,大部分研究工作来自研究评估卓越框架(RAE)等级分数为4的中心,大学中心占发表文章的74.6%。
结论 我们得出结论,与其他专业和地理区域的同等会议相比,VSGBI年会的质量非常高。