Keary Therese A, Frazier Thomas W, Busch Robyn M, Kubu Cynthia S, Iampietro Mary
Department of Psychiatry and Psychology, Section of Neuropsychology, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Epilepsia. 2007 Aug;48(8):1438-46. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2007.01098.x. Epub 2007 Apr 18.
Neuropsychological assessment can be of assistance in determining seizure lateralization in cases where EEG and MRI findings do not provide clear lateralizing data. While several studies have examined the lateralizing value of individual neuropsychological measures, clinicians are still in need of a statistically sound method that permits the incorporation of multiple neuropsychological variables to predict seizure lateralization in the individual patient.
The present study investigated the lateralizing value of several commonly used neuropsychological measures in a large sample of patients (n = 217) who eventually underwent surgical resection to treat their epilepsy. Side of surgery was used to operationally define seizure lateralization. A comparison of the relative utility of a multivariate versus univariate approach to predict seizure lateralization was conducted in temporal epilepsy cases.
The results provide evidence for the incremental validity of neuropsychological measures, other than memory and IQ tests, in the prediction of seizure lateralization in patients with medically intractable epilepsy. These data indicate that a multivariate approach increases the accuracy of prediction of seizure lateralization for temporal lobe epilepsy cases.
This study supports the use of a multivariate approach using neuropsychological measures to predict seizure lateralization in temporal epilepsy surgical candidates. Regression formulas are provided to enhance the clinical utility of these findings.
在脑电图(EEG)和磁共振成像(MRI)结果未提供明确的定侧数据的情况下,神经心理学评估有助于确定癫痫发作的定侧。虽然有几项研究探讨了个体神经心理学测量的定侧价值,但临床医生仍需要一种统计学上合理的方法,该方法能够纳入多个神经心理学变量,以预测个体患者的癫痫发作定侧。
本研究在大量最终接受手术切除治疗癫痫的患者样本(n = 217)中,调查了几种常用神经心理学测量的定侧价值。手术侧别用于操作性地定义癫痫发作定侧。对颞叶癫痫病例中多变量与单变量预测癫痫发作定侧的相对效用进行了比较。
结果为除记忆和智商测试外的神经心理学测量在预测药物难治性癫痫患者癫痫发作定侧方面的增量效度提供了证据。这些数据表明,多变量方法提高了颞叶癫痫病例癫痫发作定侧预测的准确性。
本研究支持使用多变量方法,利用神经心理学测量来预测颞叶癫痫手术候选者的癫痫发作定侧。提供了回归公式以增强这些发现的临床效用。