Wilhelm Kay, Finch Adam, Kotze Beth, Arnold Karen, McDonald Geoff, Sternhell Peter, Hudson Beaver
School of Psychiatry, University of NSW, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Australas Psychiatry. 2007 Feb;15(1):35-41. doi: 10.1080/10398560601083068.
The aim of this study was to present an overview of the Green Card Clinic, a novel brief intervention service for patients presenting to the emergency department following deliberate self-harm (DSH) or with suicidal ideation, to examine its effectiveness in terms of service utilization, and patient and clinician feedback, and to explore the correlates of repeated DSH.
The aims and structure of the Green Card Clinic are described. We highlight our patient-centred approach involving self-identification of difficulties from a list of problem areas, coupled with tailored intervention strategies. Relevant data are presented and characteristics of repeat DSH patients are compared to the first-episode group.
Between 1998 and 2005, 456 DSH patients were referred to the clinic. Of these, 75% (n = 344) attended the first session, 43% (n = 197) the second session, 26% (n = 117) the third session, and 16% (n = 73) completed a 3-15 month follow-up. Clinic attenders (mean age 31.6 years, 57% female) reported a diverse range of self-identified problems and repeat DSH patients reported worse depression, poorer health-related behaviours, and a greater number of problems than those presenting after first-episode DSH.
The clinic achieved high rates of first session attendance. This may have been attributable to the use of a few specific strategies aimed at increasing compliance, such as the green card, next-day appointments and assertive follow-up of non-attenders. For repeat self-harmers, we advocate an approach aimed at 'lifestyle change' rather than based on current psychological stressors. The Green Card Clinic service, involving a range of interventions tailored to meet the multitude of presenting needs, appears to be an acceptable and flexible approach to brief intervention for DSH.
本研究旨在概述绿卡诊所,这是一项为蓄意自伤(DSH)或有自杀意念后前往急诊科的患者提供的新型简短干预服务,从服务利用、患者及临床医生反馈方面考察其有效性,并探讨反复DSH的相关因素。
描述了绿卡诊所的目标和结构。我们强调了以患者为中心的方法,包括从一系列问题领域中自我识别困难,以及量身定制的干预策略。呈现了相关数据,并将反复DSH患者的特征与首发组进行了比较。
1998年至2005年期间,456名DSH患者被转诊至该诊所。其中,75%(n = 344)参加了第一次诊疗,43%(n = 197)参加了第二次诊疗,26%(n = 117)参加了第三次诊疗,16%(n = 73)完成了3至15个月的随访。前来诊所就诊的患者(平均年龄31.6岁,57%为女性)报告了各种各样自我识别出的问题,反复DSH患者报告的抑郁程度更严重、健康相关行为更差,且问题数量比首发DSH后就诊的患者更多。
该诊所首次诊疗的就诊率很高。这可能归因于采用了一些旨在提高依从性的特定策略,如绿卡、次日预约以及对未就诊者进行积极随访。对于反复自伤者,我们提倡一种旨在“改变生活方式”而非基于当前心理压力源的方法。绿卡诊所服务涉及一系列为满足众多呈现需求而量身定制的干预措施,似乎是一种可接受且灵活的DSH简短干预方法。