Haj-Ali Reem, Walker Mary P, Petrie Cynthia S, Steven Jasmin
Department of Restorative Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of Missouri-Kansas City, 650 East 25 Street, Kansas City, MO 64108, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2007 Apr;71(4):511-5.
The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate whether senior dental students (4DS) could serve as effective instructors in a two-semester preclinical laboratory course and whether such teaching experience could enhance their interest in academics as a future career. Based on academic performance, five senior students were recruited to serve as instructors in a two-semester morphology/occlusion laboratory course in which ninety-five first-year dental students were enrolled. The first-year students were randomly assigned so that each student was instructed by a faculty member in one semester and a 4DS in the other semester. Outcomes included course evaluation forms completed by the first-year dental students at the end of each semester; a comparison of students' performances in each course determined by faculty instructors and 4DSs; and the 4DSs' self-report of their teaching experiences. Results showed no significant difference between the performance of 4DS and faculty instructors in all criteria evaluated (p>.05). Furthermore, there was no significant difference between the performance of students instructed by faculty members and those instructed by 4DS in either semester (p>.05). Despite the fact that such experience seemed to have minimal influence on students' decision to consider academics as a future career, 4DSs do seem to provide effective instruction and thereby can serve to compensate for faculty shortages.
本研究的目的是评估高年级牙科学生(4DS)是否能在为期两个学期的临床前实验室课程中担任有效的教师,以及这种教学经历是否能增强他们对未来从事学术职业的兴趣。根据学业成绩,招募了五名高年级学生在一门为期两个学期的形态学/咬合实验室课程中担任教师,该课程有95名一年级牙科学生参加。一年级学生被随机分配,以便每个学生在一个学期由教员指导,在另一个学期由4DS指导。结果包括一年级牙科学生在每个学期末填写的课程评估表;教员和4DS确定的学生在每门课程中的表现比较;以及4DS对其教学经历的自我报告。结果显示,在所有评估标准中,4DS和教员的表现没有显著差异(p>0.05)。此外,在任何一个学期中,由教员指导的学生和由4DS指导的学生的表现也没有显著差异(p>0.05)。尽管这种经历似乎对学生将学术作为未来职业的决定影响极小,但4DS似乎确实能提供有效的教学,从而有助于弥补师资短缺。