Glover Dominic S, Brown Gary P, Fairburn Christopher G, Shafran Roz
Royal Holloway University of London, UK.
Br J Clin Psychol. 2007 Mar;46(Pt 1):85-94. doi: 10.1348/014466506x117388.
The construct of 'clinical perfectionism' has been developed in response to criticisms that other approaches have failed to yield advances in the treatment of the type of self-oriented perfectionism that poses a clinical problem. The primary aim of this study was to conduct a preliminary investigation into the efficacy of a theory-driven, cognitive-behavioural intervention for 'clinical perfectionism'.
A multiple baseline single case series design was used.
A specific, 10-session cognitive-behavioural intervention to address clinical perfectionism in eating disorders was adapted to allow its use in nine patients referred with a range of axis I disorders and clinical perfectionism.
The intervention led to clinically significant improvements in self-referential perfectionism from pretreatment to follow-up for six of the nine participants on two perfectionism measures and for three of the nine participants on the measure of clinical perfectionism. Statistically significant improvements from pre- to post-intervention for the group as a whole were found on all three measures. The improvements were maintained at follow-up.
The finding that clinical perfectionism is improved in the majority of participants is particularly encouraging given that perfectionism has traditionally been viewed as a personality characteristic resistant to change. These preliminary findings warrant replication in a larger study.
“临床完美主义”这一概念的提出,是为了回应其他方法未能在治疗构成临床问题的自我导向型完美主义方面取得进展的批评。本研究的主要目的是对一种针对“临床完美主义”的理论驱动的认知行为干预的疗效进行初步调查。
采用多基线单病例系列设计。
对一种针对饮食失调中的临床完美主义的特定的、为期10节的认知行为干预进行调整,使其可用于9名被转介的患有一系列轴I障碍和临床完美主义的患者。
在两项完美主义测量指标上,9名参与者中有6名从干预前到随访时,自我参照完美主义有了临床上显著的改善;在临床完美主义测量指标上,9名参与者中有3名有了改善。在所有三项测量指标上,整个组从干预前到干预后都有统计学上的显著改善。这些改善在随访时得以维持。
鉴于完美主义传统上被视为一种难以改变的人格特征,大多数参与者的临床完美主义得到改善这一发现尤其令人鼓舞。这些初步发现值得在更大规模的研究中进行重复验证。