Nicaise Virginie, Bois Julien E, Fairclough Stuart J, Amorose Anthony J, Cogérino Geneviève
University of Lyon, France.
J Sports Sci. 2007 Jun;25(8):915-26. doi: 10.1080/02640410600898095.
In this study, we examined the perceptions of physical education (PE) teachers' feedback patterns with female and male high school students (n = 325). Eight physical education teachers (4 females and 4 males) were involved. We examined (a) whether teachers' feedback was perceived differently by boys and girls, and how the sex of the teacher influenced these perceptions, and (b) the effects of types of feedback (praise, no response-successful, encouragement, technical information, criticism, no response-unsuccessful, and teacher's invested time) on students' perceived competence, effort, enjoyment, and their PE performance. A multivariate analysis revealed an interaction between teacher and student gender on perceptions of teacher feedback. Hierarchical regression analyses highlighted that the perceived feedback significantly predicted students' perceptions of competence (DeltaR(2) = 0.088), effort (DeltaR(2) = 0.119), enjoyment (DeltaR(2) = 0.085), and their PE performance (DeltaR(2) = 0.039) after accounting for the gender of the students and teachers and the students' initial PE performance. The perceptions of praise and teachers' invested time were positively linked with the dependent variables, whereas encouragement and technical information and criticism were negatively linked. The findings are discussed in terms of teaching effectiveness and gender equity.
在本研究中,我们调查了高中女生和男生(n = 325)对体育教师反馈模式的看法。共有8名体育教师(4名女性和4名男性)参与其中。我们研究了:(a)男生和女生对教师反馈的感知是否存在差异,以及教师的性别如何影响这些感知;(b)不同类型的反馈(表扬、无回应 - 成功、鼓励、技术信息、批评、无回应 - 不成功以及教师投入的时间)对学生的感知能力、努力程度、享受程度及其体育成绩的影响。多变量分析揭示了教师和学生性别在对教师反馈的感知上存在交互作用。分层回归分析强调,在考虑了学生和教师的性别以及学生最初的体育成绩后,感知到的反馈能显著预测学生对能力的感知(ΔR² = 0.088)、努力程度(ΔR² = 0.119)、享受程度(ΔR² = 0.085)以及他们的体育成绩(ΔR² = 0.039)。表扬和教师投入的时间的感知与因变量呈正相关,而鼓励、技术信息和批评与因变量呈负相关。我们从教学效果和性别平等的角度对研究结果进行了讨论。