Khalil T, Lemaire J-J, Chazal J, Verrelle P
Service de neurochirurgie A, hôpital Gabriel-Montpied, CHU, 63003 Clermont-Ferrand cedex, France.
Neurochirurgie. 2007 Jun;53(2-3 Pt 2):238-42. doi: 10.1016/j.neuchi.2007.03.004.
From a review of the literature dealing with radiosurgery of cavernous malformations, we have analyzed its impact on hemorrhagic risk, epilepsy, histological modifications, morbidity and potential indications of treatment. Radiosurgery could significantly reduce the hemorrhagic risk, in a selected population with a high risk of hemorrhage, after an interval of about 2 years, but cannot provide protection against rebleeding. As for epilepsy related to the lesion, a significant reduction of seizures has been observed in certain cases, with better control in case of recent evolution and simple seizures linked to the site of the vascular malformation. Histologic lesions are vascular fibrosis, fibrinoid necrosis and ferrugination, without good correlation with results of CT scan or MRI. Morbidity of radiosurgery seems higher compared to other diseases with similar doses and target volumes. The rate of transient complications was about 25%, with permanent sequelae in 5 to 10% of patients. This would be due to a radiosensitizing effect of the hemosiderin halo around the lesion. Radiosurgery can be proposed for non-surgical lesions with a high risk of hemorrhage, nevertheless the superiority of the technique over conservative treatment has to be proven. Without long-term prospective studies, the efficiency of RS for cavernomas remains questionable and subject to debate. New imaging methods proving the obstruction of the cavernous malformation are needed.
通过对有关海绵状血管畸形放射外科治疗的文献综述,我们分析了其对出血风险、癫痫、组织学改变、发病率及潜在治疗指征的影响。放射外科可在约2年的间隔期后,显著降低特定高出血风险人群的出血风险,但无法预防再出血。对于与病变相关的癫痫,在某些病例中观察到癫痫发作显著减少,近期发病且与血管畸形部位相关的单纯性发作控制效果更佳。组织学病变为血管纤维化、纤维蛋白样坏死和铁质沉着,与CT扫描或MRI结果无良好相关性。与其他具有相似剂量和靶体积的疾病相比,放射外科的发病率似乎更高。短暂并发症发生率约为25%,5%至10%的患者有永久性后遗症。这可能归因于病变周围含铁血黄素晕的放射增敏作用。对于有高出血风险的非手术性病变可考虑放射外科治疗,不过该技术相对于保守治疗的优越性尚待证实。若无长期前瞻性研究,放射外科治疗海绵状血管瘤的有效性仍存疑问且有待探讨。需要新的成像方法来证实海绵状血管畸形的阻塞情况。