Montironi R, Scarpelli M, Braccischi A, Magi Galluzzi C, Diamanti L, Alberti R
Institute of Morbid Anatomy and Histopathology, University of Ancona, Italy.
Virchows Arch A Pathol Anat Histopathol. 1991;419(6):505-12. doi: 10.1007/BF01650680.
The diagnostic value of nucleolar margination, defined as the percentage of nucleoli touching the nuclear membrane, was investigated in 359 cytological preparations of benign and malignant lesions of the thyroid, breast, prostate and central nervous system. Premalignant lesions of the uterine cervix and non-invasive papillary carcinomas of the bladder were also examined. It was observed that the percentages in benign lesions were, in general, lower than in the malignant and that the values increased progressively with increasing grade in the cervix and bladder. When the overlap index was calculated, this gave exact information on the usefulness of nucleolar margination in distinguishing benign from malignant lesions, particularly in the prostate and thyroid and, to a lesser extent, in the breast and central nervous system. As for lesions of different grades, the calculation of the index allowed the identification of two subgroups, one corresponding to low grades (mild cervical dysplasia or urothelial papillary carcinoma of grade 1), the other subgroup to high grades (severe cervical dysplasia and carcinoma in situ, or papillary carcinoma of grade 3). Moderate dysplasia cases and grade 2 papillary carcinomas do not appear as separate intermediate categories but rather show values falling into the range of either the higher or lower grades. The margination values obtained from the cytological preparations corresponded well to those in the histological slides obtained from the resected specimens. In conclusion, nucleolar margination appears to be a feature which is easy to evaluate in a reproducible way and useful in cytological diagnosis.
对359份甲状腺、乳腺、前列腺和中枢神经系统良恶性病变的细胞学标本,研究了核仁边缘化的诊断价值,其定义为接触核膜的核仁百分比。还检查了子宫颈的癌前病变和膀胱的非浸润性乳头状癌。观察到良性病变中的百分比一般低于恶性病变,并且在子宫颈和膀胱中,随着分级增加,该值逐渐升高。计算重叠指数时,其能准确提供核仁边缘化在区分良性与恶性病变中的有用信息,尤其是在前列腺和甲状腺中,在乳腺和中枢神经系统中作用较小。对于不同分级的病变,计算该指数可识别出两个亚组,一个对应低分级(轻度宫颈发育异常或1级尿路上皮乳头状癌),另一个亚组对应高分级(重度宫颈发育异常和原位癌,或3级乳头状癌)。中度发育异常病例和2级乳头状癌并非表现为单独的中间类别,而是显示其值落入高分级或低分级范围内。从细胞学标本获得的边缘化值与从切除标本获得的组织学切片中的值非常吻合。总之,核仁边缘化似乎是一种易于以可重复方式评估且对细胞学诊断有用的特征。