Dines Joshua S, Elkousy Hussein, Edwards T Bradley, Gartsman Gary M, Dines David M
Kerlan-Jobe Orthopaedic Clinic, New York, New York, NY, USA.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2007 Jul-Aug;16(4):434-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jse.2006.10.016. Epub 2007 May 15.
There are few reports in the literature on the effect of orthopaedic implants on airport security devices and none on shoulder arthroplasty implants after September 11, 2001. Since 9/11, airport security screening devices have become more sensitive in response to the increasing threat of terrorism. Often, patients with joint implants activate the metal detectors and are subsequently subjected to more intensive screening. We assess the effects of shoulder joint implants on different airport security devices and what effect the results had on passenger travel. In this study, 154 patients who had previously undergone shoulder replacement responded to a questionnaire regarding their travel experiences after 9/11. Of these, 85 had flown during the time period studied (47 men and 38 women; mean age, 67.8 years); 79 had traveled domestically (mean, 7 flights), and 22 had taken international flights (mean, 6.1 flights). The questionnaire addressed each patient's height/weight, the number of flight segments flown (domestic and international), the number of times that a patient activated the doorway alarm/wand alarm, and the effect of a card stating that the patient had joint replacement (when applicable). On average, patients with shoulder replacement traveling domestically activated the security gate 52% of the time. The average for international travel was 42%. Of the patients who flew both domestically and internationally, there was a high correlation of activation (R = 0.54). Twenty-six patients had multiple joint implants (mean, 2.8). Multiple joint implants caused increased alarm activation (P < .001). All patients reported that their travel was delayed during the instances of security activation. There was no statistically significant effect of body mass index, height, weight, age, or sex on security device activation. Of the patients, 71% were told by their doctor that the shoulder replacement may activate security devices. Of these, 46 were given a card by their doctor indicating the presence of a total joint implant. In only 30% of the security encounters of these patients did the card expedite the screening process. This is the largest study on the effects of joint implants, and shoulder implants in particular, on airport security devices and the only one that has analyzed the data of post-9/11 travel. Patients traveling after total shoulder replacement are often delayed and subjected to more rigorous screening when traveling, especially in the post-9/11 environment. Doctors often warn their patients of potential problems and may try to avert this by giving them cards documenting the presence of a joint implant. The acceptance of these cards is sporadic. This study raises the importance of notifying patients of potential security delays, especially those with multiple joint implants, as they may directly affect travel plans. In addition, these patients may benefit from the establishment of an international joint registry.
关于骨科植入物对机场安检设备的影响,文献报道较少,2001年9月11日之后关于肩关节置换植入物的报道则没有。自9·11事件以来,由于恐怖主义威胁不断增加,机场安检设备变得更加灵敏。通常,植入关节的患者会触发金属探测器,随后要接受更严格的检查。我们评估了肩关节植入物对不同机场安检设备的影响以及这些结果对旅客出行有何影响。在这项研究中,154名曾接受过肩关节置换的患者就他们在9·11事件后的出行经历回复了一份问卷。其中,85人在研究期间乘坐过飞机(47名男性和38名女性;平均年龄67.8岁);79人在国内出行(平均7次航班),22人乘坐过国际航班(平均6.1次航班)。问卷涉及每位患者的身高/体重、飞行航段数量(国内和国际)、触发门道警报/手持探测器警报的次数,以及(如适用)携带表明患者接受过关节置换的卡片所产生的影响。平均而言,接受肩关节置换的患者在国内出行时52%的情况下会触发安检门。国际出行的平均比例为42%。在国内和国际都乘坐过飞机的患者中,触发警报的相关性很高(R = 0.54)。26名患者有多个关节植入物(平均2.8个)。多个关节植入物导致警报触发增加(P < 0.001)。所有患者都报告说,在安检触发时他们的行程被延误。体重指数、身高、体重、年龄或性别对安检设备触发没有统计学上的显著影响。71%的患者被医生告知肩关节置换可能会触发安检设备。其中,46人从医生那里拿到了一张表明有全关节植入物的卡片。在这些患者的安检过程中,只有30%的情况下卡片加快了检查流程。这是关于关节植入物,特别是肩关节植入物对机场安检设备影响的最大规模研究,也是唯一一项分析9·11事件后出行数据的研究。全肩关节置换术后出行的患者在旅行时经常会被延误并接受更严格的检查,尤其是在9·11事件后的环境中。医生经常会提醒患者可能存在的问题,并可能试图通过给他们提供记录关节植入物情况的卡片来避免这种情况。这些卡片的接受情况并不稳定。这项研究凸显了告知患者可能出现安检延误的重要性,特别是那些有多个关节植入物的患者,因为这可能会直接影响旅行计划。此外,这些患者可能会从建立一个国际联合登记处中受益。