Badawi-Fayad Jackie, Cabanis Emmanuel-Alain
Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Département de Préhistoire USM 204, Institut de Paléontologie Humaine, Paris, France.
Anat Rec (Hoboken). 2007 Mar;290(3):268-76. doi: 10.1002/ar.20442.
The objective of this study was to analyze modern human craniofacial form using 3D Procrustes superimposition in order to establish a reference model and validate it on computed tomography (CT). The sample consists of 136 specimens from five modern human regional groups. Thirty-three craniofacial landmark coordinates have been recorded using a Microscribe and calculated on CT scans for five crania from the sample. Procrustes superimposition has been performed to calculate the mean shape, and a discriminant analysis has also been carried out to estimate the variability of shape. The results show that the repeatability of measurements made on CT and on Microscribe is excellent (R = 0.99). There is no major distinctiveness in the craniofacial shape; however, discriminant function 1 separates out the European crania from the others, especially African and American. It includes the width and the length of the face, the flatness of the upper face, the prognathism of the maxilla, as well as the length and the inclination of the palate. The width of the maxilla and the palate do not show a great variability. This may be the common invariant feature responsible for the alignment of the teeth in all specimens. It may correspond to functional patterns related to masticatory constraints manifested by the important interproximal and occlusal dental wear in all specimens. This study confirms the high accuracy of measurements made on CT scan and the importance of geometric morphometrics, which provides an accurate characterization of the overall craniofacial shape and its variation within the entire population.
本研究的目的是使用三维普洛斯特叠加法分析现代人类的颅面形态,以建立一个参考模型并在计算机断层扫描(CT)上进行验证。样本包括来自五个现代人类区域群体的136个标本。使用Microscribe记录了33个颅面地标坐标,并对样本中的五个颅骨进行了CT扫描计算。进行了普洛斯特叠加以计算平均形状,还进行了判别分析以估计形状的变异性。结果表明,在CT和Microscribe上进行的测量的重复性极佳(R = 0.99)。颅面形状没有明显的显著差异;然而,判别函数1将欧洲颅骨与其他颅骨区分开来,尤其是非洲和美洲的颅骨。它包括面部的宽度和长度、上脸的平整度、上颌的前突度,以及腭的长度和倾斜度。上颌和腭的宽度没有很大的变异性。这可能是所有标本中牙齿排列的共同不变特征。它可能对应于与咀嚼限制相关的功能模式,并表现为所有标本中重要的邻面和咬合面牙齿磨损。本研究证实了CT扫描测量的高精度以及几何形态计量学的重要性,几何形态计量学能够准确描述整个颅面形状及其在整个人口中的变化。