Kodama Ken, Oda Kazuyuki, Okami Jiro, Maeda Jun, Wang Lei, Higashiyama Masahiko, Nakayama Tomio
Department of Thoracic Surgery, Osaka Medical Center for Cancer and Cardiovascular Diseases, Osaka, Japan.
Nihon Geka Gakkai Zasshi. 2007 May;108(3):107-12.
This study was conducted to elucidate the real benefit of postoperative long-term surveillance for 10 years in patients who underwent curative resection for pathological stage I lung cancer. In 1995 and 1996, 100 patients with p-stage I lung cancer underwent curative resection. Of those, 20 patients were excluded because they did not comply with the follow-up regimen. Our follow-up regimen comprised a physical examination including a posterolateral chest radiograph and blood laboratory test every 6 months for up to 2 years, followed by once a year up to 10 years after resection. In addition, CT generally encompassed the lung apices to the lowest edge of the liver and was performed with intravenous contrast once every two years. As a result, among 80 patients, nine recurrences (11%) and seven metachronous second primary lung cancers (9%) were detected. Of 16 malignancies detected, six underwent curative reoperation The 5-year survival rates after the discovery of recurrence and of second primary lung cancer were 22% and 72%, respectively. The average survival of the six reoperated patients was 226 days longer than that of the remaining patients. For the calculation of the costs per life-year gained (LYG) of our follow-up program, an estimated survival benefit of 226 days was used. Consequently, the costs per LYG were calculated at almost 4,500,000 yen. In conclusion, the costs per LYG seem to be acceptable in the light of Japanese average annual earnings. In addition, this follow-up regimen seemed to show a clear survival benefit for patients with metachronous second primary lung cancer. However, for patients with lung cancer recurrence, the perceived benefit was nominal.
本研究旨在阐明对病理分期为I期肺癌且接受根治性切除的患者进行术后10年长期监测的实际益处。1995年和1996年,100例p-I期肺癌患者接受了根治性切除。其中,20例患者因未遵守随访方案而被排除。我们的随访方案包括每6个月进行一次体格检查,包括后外侧胸部X光片和血液实验室检查,持续2年,之后在切除后长达10年的时间里每年进行一次。此外,CT扫描一般涵盖肺尖至肝脏最低边缘,每两年进行一次静脉造影。结果,在80例患者中,检测到9例复发(11%)和7例异时性第二原发性肺癌(9%)。在检测到的16例恶性肿瘤中,6例接受了根治性再次手术。复发和第二原发性肺癌发现后的5年生存率分别为22%和72%。6例再次手术患者的平均生存期比其余患者长226天。为了计算我们随访计划每获得一个生命年(LYG)的成本,使用了估计为226天的生存益处。因此,每LYG的成本计算为近450万日元。总之,根据日本的平均年收入,每LYG的成本似乎是可以接受的。此外,这种随访方案似乎对异时性第二原发性肺癌患者显示出明显的生存益处。然而,对于肺癌复发患者,所感知到的益处微不足道。