Reeve Julie, Denehy Linda, Stiller Kathy
School of Physiotherapy, Faculty of Health and Environmental Studies, Auckland University of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand.
Physiother Res Int. 2007 Jun;12(2):59-71. doi: 10.1002/pri.354.
Physiotherapy is considered an essential component of the management of patients after thoracotomy, yet the type of interventions utilized, and evidence for their efficacy, has not been established. The aim of the present study was to ascertain the current physiotherapy management of patients undergoing thoracotomy and the factors influencing practice among different providers.
A purpose-designed postal questionnaire was distributed to senior physiotherapists in all thoracic surgical units throughout Australia and New Zealand (n=57).
A response rate of 81% was obtained (n=46). Pre-operatively, 16 respondents (35%) reported assessing all thoracotomy patients. The majority of respondents (n=44; 96%) indicated that all patients were seen by physiotherapists after surgery, with 29 respondents (63%) performing prophylactic physiotherapy interventions to prevent post-operative pulmonary complications. Respondents reported that physiotherapy treatment was usually commenced on day one post-operatively (n=37; 80%) with the most commonly used treatment interventions being deep breathing exercises, the active cycle of breathing techniques, cough, forced expiration techniques and sustained maximal inspirations. Most respondents reported that patients first sat out of bed (n=41; 89%), commenced shoulder range of movement (n=23; 50%) and walking (n=32; 70%) on day one post-operatively. The majority of respondents reported that they offered no post-operative pulmonary rehabilitation (n=25; 54%), outpatient follow-up (n=43; 94%) orpost-thoracotomy pain management (n=40; 87%). Respondents indicated that personal experience, literature recommendations and established practice were the factors which most influenced physiotherapy practice. Conclusion. Most patients after thoracotomy receive physiotherapy assessment and/or treatment in the immediate post-operative period, but only one-third were routinely seen pre-operatively and relatively few were reviewed following discharge from hospital. Further studies are required to guide physiotherapists in determining the efficacy of their practices for patients undergoing thoracotomy.
物理治疗被认为是开胸术后患者管理的重要组成部分,然而所采用的干预类型及其疗效证据尚未确立。本研究的目的是确定目前开胸手术患者的物理治疗管理情况以及不同提供者之间影响实践的因素。
向澳大利亚和新西兰所有胸外科单位的高级物理治疗师发放了一份专门设计的邮政问卷(n = 57)。
获得了81%的回复率(n = 46)。术前,16名受访者(35%)报告对所有开胸手术患者进行评估。大多数受访者(n = 44;96%)表示所有患者术后都接受了物理治疗师的诊治,29名受访者(63%)进行预防性物理治疗干预以预防术后肺部并发症。受访者报告物理治疗通常在术后第一天开始(n = 37;80%),最常用的治疗干预措施是深呼吸练习、主动呼吸循环技术、咳嗽、用力呼气技术和持续最大吸气。大多数受访者报告患者术后第一天首次坐起(n = 41;89%)、开始进行肩部活动范围练习(n = 23;50%)和行走(n = 32;70%)。大多数受访者报告他们没有提供术后肺部康复(n = 25;54%)、门诊随访(n = 43;94%)或开胸术后疼痛管理(n = 40;87%)。受访者表示个人经验、文献建议和既定实践是对物理治疗实践影响最大的因素。结论:大多数开胸术后患者在术后即刻接受了物理治疗评估和/或治疗,但只有三分之一的患者在术前常规接受诊治,出院后接受复查的相对较少。需要进一步研究以指导物理治疗师确定其对开胸手术患者的治疗方法的疗效。