Klemmensen Ase K, Olsen Sjurdur F, Osterdal Marie Louise, Tabor Ann
Maternal Nutrition Group, Danish Epidemiology Science Centre, Statens Serum Institut, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Am J Epidemiol. 2007 Jul 15;166(2):117-24. doi: 10.1093/aje/kwm139. Epub 2007 Jun 7.
In a population-based sample, the authors examined the validity of preeclampsia and related diagnoses recorded in a mandatory Danish national hospital discharge registry and in a standardized telephone interview of women who gave birth between 1998 and 2002. Using a "gold standard" for preeclampsia defined in accordance with the guidelines from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the authors reviewed hospital charts of 3,039 women and found that 61 of 88 preeclampsia cases (69.3%) and 24 of 55 cases of serious subtypes of preeclampsia (43.6%) were recorded as such by the registry. A total of 21 of 2,951 women without preeclampsia (0.71%) had a preeclampsia diagnosis in the registry. All registrations of serious subtypes of preeclampsia reflected true cases. The positive predictive value of a preeclampsia diagnosis in the registry was 74.4%. Including interview data reduced the sample size to 2,307 women. In this sample, of 62 women with preeclampsia, 45 (72.6%) reported in the interview to have had preeclampsia. Of 2,245 women with no preeclampsia, 31 (1.4%) reported to have had preeclampsia. The positive predictive value of the women's own report on preeclampsia was 59.2%. The authors conclude, for the purpose of etiologic studies, that the registry had acceptable validity, whereas the usefulness of self-reported information may be limited.
在一个基于人群的样本中,作者检查了丹麦强制性国家医院出院登记处记录的先兆子痫及相关诊断的有效性,并对1998年至2002年间分娩的女性进行了标准化电话访谈。作者采用根据美国妇产科医师学会指南定义的先兆子痫“金标准”,查阅了3039名女性的医院病历,发现登记处记录了88例先兆子痫病例中的61例(69.3%)以及55例先兆子痫严重亚型病例中的24例(43.6%)。在2951名无先兆子痫的女性中,共有21名(0.71%)在登记处有先兆子痫诊断。先兆子痫严重亚型的所有登记均反映了真实病例。登记处先兆子痫诊断的阳性预测值为74.4%。纳入访谈数据后,样本量减少至2307名女性。在这个样本中,62名患有先兆子痫的女性中,有45名(72.6%)在访谈中报告患有先兆子痫。在2245名无先兆子痫的女性中,有31名(1.4%)报告患有先兆子痫。女性自身关于先兆子痫报告的阳性预测值为59.2%。作者得出结论,就病因学研究而言,登记处具有可接受的有效性,而自我报告信息的有用性可能有限。