Awata Shuichi
Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi. 2007;109(4):348-53.
In order to discuss the future direction of the guideline for electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in Japan, the present situation of the study was described after investigation of the original papers regarding clinical studies on ECT in Japan published between 1983-2005. The total number of original papers obtained was 290, which was rapidly increasing in recent years at 50 per year in 2005. These papers support overall the Criteria of Indication for ECT presented in the ECT Recommendation of the Japanese Society of Psychiatry and Neurology. However, the majority of these studies are case reports and thus the evidence level is not so high. To systematically accumulate the evidence of high quality, multi-institute collaborative studies should be conducted. To facilitate making database for evidence, revising guideline, and opening information to the public, the ECT Task Force should be established within the Committee of Guideline for Mental Disorders. Additionally, it is necessary to study the experience and the degree of satisfaction of users of ECT.
为探讨日本电休克治疗(ECT)指南的未来方向,在对1983 - 2005年间发表的关于日本ECT临床研究的原始论文进行调查后,描述了研究现状。获得的原始论文总数为290篇,近年来呈快速增长趋势,2005年达到每年50篇。这些论文总体上支持了日本精神神经学会ECT推荐中提出的ECT适应症标准。然而,这些研究大多是病例报告,因此证据水平不高。为系统地积累高质量证据,应开展多机构合作研究。为便于建立证据数据库、修订指南并向公众公开信息,应在精神障碍指南委员会内设立ECT特别工作组。此外,有必要研究ECT使用者的体验和满意度。