Leslie Laurel K, Plemmons Dena, Monn Amy R, Palinkas Lawrence A
Child and Adolescent Services Research Center, Children's Hospital, San Diego, CA 92123-0282, USA.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2007 Jun;28(3):179-88. doi: 10.1097/DBP.0b013e3180324d9a.
Policymakers, federal agencies, and researchers have called for more in-depth investigation of contextual mechanisms that may explain differences in medication use among youths with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
We conducted qualitative interviews with 28 families from varied socioeconomic and racial/ethnic and linguistic backgrounds regarding diagnostic and treatment trajectories for their children with symptoms consistent with ADHD, with a particular focus on whether and how medication use became a part of the trajectory.
Four longitudinal patterns of help-seeking trajectories emerged: (1) a pattern characterized by delay to diagnosis, common among youths with complicated clinical and/or environmental pictures or primarily inattentive ADHD symptoms; (2) an initial nonmedication treatment pattern in which parents at first chose to use other modalities of treatment; (3) a reluctant receipt of an ADHD diagnosis and/or treatment pattern, mainly seen among the low-income, Spanish-speaking families; and (4) a rapid engagement in medication use pattern, characterized by directed movement to and maintenance of medication use. These patterns resulted from a dynamic interplay of explanatory models regarding the cause, course, and cure of a child's problems; the influence of extended social networks; and factors previously examined in medical utilization models. Additional themes included (1) parents' need for more information about ADHD, (2) families' desire for additional mental health and school services making medications less necessary, and (3) the importance of cultural sensitivity and a longitudinal relationship between the caregiver and clinician to enhance communication between families and clinicians.
These findings deserve further study in a larger, more diverse sample.
政策制定者、联邦机构和研究人员呼吁对可能解释注意力缺陷/多动障碍(ADHD)青少年药物使用差异的背景机制进行更深入的调查。
我们对28个来自不同社会经济、种族/民族和语言背景的家庭进行了定性访谈,了解他们患有与ADHD症状相符的孩子的诊断和治疗轨迹,特别关注药物使用是否以及如何成为轨迹的一部分。
出现了四种寻求帮助轨迹的纵向模式:(1)以诊断延迟为特征的模式,常见于临床和/或环境情况复杂或主要表现为注意力不集中的ADHD症状的青少年中;(2)初始非药物治疗模式,即父母首先选择使用其他治疗方式;(3)不情愿接受ADHD诊断和/或治疗模式,主要见于低收入、讲西班牙语的家庭;(4)快速使用药物模式,其特征是直接转向并维持药物使用。这些模式源于关于儿童问题的原因、病程和治疗的解释模型之间的动态相互作用;扩展社交网络的影响;以及先前在医疗利用模型中研究过的因素。其他主题包括:(1)父母需要更多关于ADHD的信息;(2)家庭希望获得更多心理健康和学校服务,从而减少药物使用的必要性;(3)文化敏感性以及照顾者与临床医生之间的长期关系对于加强家庭与临床医生之间沟通的重要性。
这些发现值得在更大、更多样化的样本中进一步研究。