Camp Bonnie W
Department of Pediatrics, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Denver, CO 80222, USA.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2007 Jun;28(3):234-40. doi: 10.1097/DBP.0b013e318065b825.
This commentary describes six potential problems and sources of bias that are often overlooked and under-reported in validity studies of developmental/behavioral screening tests, namely, 1) problems with small samples, 2) verification bias, 3) inappropriate/non-equivalent test bias, 4) procedural bias, 5) incomplete reporting of results, and 6) spectrum bias. These issues are then applied to review an unusually complete published report of a screening test validity study along with a discussion of how results may affect application in different settings.
本评论描述了在发育/行为筛查测试的效度研究中经常被忽视和报告不足的六个潜在问题及偏差来源,即:1)小样本问题;2)验证偏差;3)不适当/不等同测试偏差;4)程序偏差;5)结果报告不完整;6)谱带偏差。随后将这些问题应用于对一份异常完整的筛查测试效度研究已发表报告的回顾,并讨论结果可能如何影响在不同环境中的应用。