Litvak Vladimir, Komssi Soile, Scherg Michael, Hoechstetter Karsten, Classen Joseph, Zaaroor Menashe, Pratt Hillel, Kahkonen Seppo
Faculty of Biomedical Engineering, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Neuroimage. 2007 Aug 1;37(1):56-70. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2007.05.015. Epub 2007 May 18.
Analyzing the brain responses to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) using electroencephalography (EEG) is a promising method for the assessment of functional cortical connectivity and excitability of areas accessible to this stimulation. However, until now it has been difficult to analyze the EEG responses during the several tens of milliseconds immediately following the stimulus due to TMS-induced artifacts. In the present study we show that by combining a specially adapted recording system with software artifact correction it is possible to remove a major part of the artifact and analyze the cortical responses as early as 10 ms after TMS. We used this methodology to examine responses of left and right primary motor cortex (M1) to TMS at different intensities. Based on the artifact-corrected data we propose a model for the cortical activation following M1 stimulation. The model revealed the same basic response sequence for both hemispheres. A large part of the response could be accounted for by two sources: a source close to the stimulation site (peaking approximately 15 ms after the stimulus) and a midline frontal source ipsilateral to the stimulus (peaking approximately 25 ms). In addition the model suggests responses in ipsilateral temporo-parietal junction areas (approximately 35 ms) and ipsilateral (approximately 30 ms) and middle (approximately 50 ms) cerebellum. Statistical analysis revealed significant dependence on stimulation intensity for the ipsilateral midline frontal source. The methodology developed in the present study paves the way for the detailed study of early responses to TMS in a wide variety of brain areas.
利用脑电图(EEG)分析大脑对经颅磁刺激(TMS)的反应,是评估该刺激可及区域的功能性皮质连接和兴奋性的一种很有前景的方法。然而,到目前为止,由于TMS诱发的伪迹,在刺激后的几十毫秒内分析EEG反应一直很困难。在本研究中,我们表明,通过将经过特殊改装的记录系统与软件伪迹校正相结合,有可能去除大部分伪迹,并最早在TMS后10毫秒分析皮质反应。我们使用这种方法来检测左右初级运动皮层(M1)对不同强度TMS的反应。基于经过伪迹校正的数据,我们提出了一个M1刺激后皮质激活的模型。该模型揭示了两个半球相同的基本反应序列。大部分反应可由两个来源解释:一个靠近刺激部位的来源(在刺激后约15毫秒达到峰值)和一个与刺激同侧的中线额叶来源(在刺激后约25毫秒达到峰值)。此外,该模型还表明同侧颞顶叶交界处区域(约35毫秒)以及同侧(约30毫秒)和中部(约50毫秒)小脑有反应。统计分析显示,同侧中线额叶来源对刺激强度有显著依赖性。本研究中开发的方法为详细研究各种脑区对TMS的早期反应铺平了道路。