Colleau J J
Station de Génétique quantitative et appliquée, Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, Jouy-en-Josas, France.
J Dairy Sci. 1991 Nov;74(11):3973-84. doi: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(91)78592-5.
Two types of multiple ovulation and embryo transfer schemes that included bull progeny testing were compared. In the juvenile schemes, embryos were collected at 16 to 18 mo of age without sexing, whereas, in the adult schemes, donors were chosen based on their first lactation record, and their embryos were systematically sexed. With the latter schemes, natural calves obtained at the first two calvings could compete with embryo transfer calves to be replacements. The optimal structure of this scheme was derived algebraically for the same number of transferred embryos as in the juvenile schemes. Predicted asymptotic annual genetic gains, after stabilization of genetic parameters taking into account the Bulmer effect, were found to be slightly in favor of the adult schemes for a given set of parameters (overall number of transferred embryos, number of embryos per collection, and embryo survival rate). In the adult schemes, the nucleus sizes were much larger than in the juvenile schemes, which allowed a higher selection differential on male paths, thus compensating for the longer generation interval. Asymptotic rate of genetic gain for Monte Carlo simulations were about 10 and 7% lower for juvenile and adult schemes, respectively, but still higher (20%) than the predicted value for the corresponding conventional scheme. Consequently, adult schemes with embryo sexing can be an efficient alternative to juvenile schemes without embryo sexing.
比较了两种包括公牛后代测试的多次排卵和胚胎移植方案。在幼年方案中,在16至18月龄时收集胚胎,不进行性别鉴定;而在成年方案中,根据母牛的第一泌乳记录选择供体,并对其胚胎进行系统的性别鉴定。采用后一种方案,前两胎产的自然犊牛可与胚胎移植犊牛竞争作为后备牛。对于与幼年方案中相同数量的移植胚胎,通过代数方法得出了该方案的最佳结构。在考虑布尔默效应的遗传参数稳定后,预测的渐近年度遗传进展在给定的一组参数(移植胚胎总数、每次采集的胚胎数和胚胎存活率)下略有利于成年方案。在成年方案中,核心群规模比幼年方案大得多,这使得在雄性系谱上有更高的选择差异,从而弥补了较长的世代间隔。蒙特卡洛模拟的渐近遗传进展率在幼年和成年方案中分别比预测值低约10%和7%,但仍高于相应传统方案的预测值(20%)。因此,带有胚胎性别鉴定的成年方案可以成为不进行胚胎性别鉴定的幼年方案的有效替代方案。