Einstein Mark H, Kadish Anna S, Burk Robert D, Kim Mimi Y, Wadler Scott, Streicher Howard, Goldberg Gary L, Runowicz Carolyn D
Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and Albert Einstein Cancer Center, Bronx, NY 10461, USA.
Gynecol Oncol. 2007 Sep;106(3):453-60. doi: 10.1016/j.ygyno.2007.04.038. Epub 2007 Jun 22.
SGN-00101 (HspE7, Nventa, San Diego, CA) is a novel therapeutic vaccine consisting of a fusion protein containing an M. bovis BCG heat shock protein (Hsp65) covalently linked to the entire sequence of HPV 16 E7. This trial was designed to evaluate the efficacy and toxicities of HspE7 in women with CIN III.
HIV (-) women with biopsy-proven CIN III were eligible. Two cohorts were accrued; one cohort to establish efficacy and a second cohort with a longer follow-up period to improve the precision of the trial to estimate response rates. Each patient underwent 3 monthly subcutaneous vaccinations with 500 microg of HspE7 followed by monthly colposcopic follow-up for 1 month in cohort 1 and an extended observation period (2 months) in cohort 2. All patients then underwent a LEEP or cone biopsy of the cervix. A complete pathologic response (pCR) was defined as no evidence of CIN or CIN I (only HPV changes). A partial response (PR) was defined as colposcopic lesion regression of >50% in size. Cervicovaginal lavage samples were obtained at each visit for HPV typing using MY09/ MY11 HPV PCR.
Seventy-two patients were registered and screened, of whom 64 were eligible. Fifty-eight patients completed the trial and were evaluable (31 in cohort 1, 27 in cohort 2). There were no significant epidemiologic or HPV type differences between the 2 cohorts so responses were combined for analysis. Of the 58 evaluable patients, 13 (22.5%) had a pCR; 32 (55%) had a PR and 11 (19%) had stable disease. Two (3.5%) patients in cohort 2 had microinvasive disease and were defined as progressive disease. Thirty-three of 58 (57%) of the patients were infected with HPV 16 prior to vaccination or in subsequent visits. There was no significant difference in regression in women infected with HPV 16 compared to those without HPV 16 infection (88% vs. 70%; p=0.12). Women who had a previous LEEP or ablation for CIN were 2.7 times more likely to have a complete response compared to patients without previous treatment, although the difference was not statistically significant (95% CI for rate ratio: 0.95-6.19, p=0.10). At a cellular level, there was a significant association between local inflammation and response; lower grade of lesional inflammation correlated with a response to HspE7 (p=0.04 using Wilcoxon rank sum test).
HspE7 appeared to demonstrate activity in women with CIN III and met a priori assumptions for efficacy; however, it is unclear whether this response was due to natural regression rather than treatment effect. HspE7, which targets the HPV 16 E7 oncoprotein, had efficacy in patients infected with HPV types other than 16, suggesting cross-reactivity. A larger randomized, controlled trial is needed to better define efficacy and to identify subsets of women most likely to benefit from immunotherapy.
SGN - 00101(HspE7,Nventa公司,加利福尼亚州圣地亚哥)是一种新型治疗性疫苗,由一种融合蛋白组成,该融合蛋白包含与HPV 16 E7全序列共价连接的牛分枝杆菌卡介苗热休克蛋白(Hsp65)。本试验旨在评估HspE7对III级宫颈上皮内瘤变(CIN III)女性的疗效和毒性。
经活检证实为CIN III的HIV(-)女性符合条件。招募了两个队列;一个队列用于确定疗效,另一个队列随访期更长,以提高试验估计缓解率的精度。每位患者每月皮下注射500μg HspE7,共3次,随后在队列1中每月进行1个月的阴道镜随访,在队列2中进行延长观察期(2个月)。所有患者随后均接受宫颈环形电切术(LEEP)或宫颈锥形活检。完全病理缓解(pCR)定义为无CIN或CIN I证据(仅HPV改变)。部分缓解(PR)定义为阴道镜下病变大小缩小>50%。每次就诊时采集宫颈阴道灌洗样本,使用MY09/MY11 HPV PCR进行HPV分型。
72例患者登记并接受筛查,其中64例符合条件。58例患者完成试验并可评估(队列1中有31例,队列2中有27例)。两个队列之间在流行病学或HPV类型上无显著差异,因此将缓解情况合并进行分析。在58例可评估患者中,13例(22.5%)达到pCR;32例(55%)达到PR,11例(19%)疾病稳定。队列2中有2例(3.5%)患者发生微浸润癌,被定义为疾病进展。58例患者中有33例(57%)在接种疫苗前或后续就诊时感染了HPV 16。与未感染HPV 16的女性相比,感染HPV 16的女性病变消退情况无显著差异(88%对70%;p = 0.12)。与未接受过治疗的患者相比,既往因CIN接受过LEEP或消融治疗的女性完全缓解的可能性高2.7倍,尽管差异无统计学意义(率比的95%置信区间:0.95 - 6.19,p = 0.10)。在细胞水平上,局部炎症与缓解之间存在显著关联;病变炎症程度较低与对HspE7的反应相关(使用Wilcoxon秩和检验,p = 0.04)。
HspE7似乎在CIN III女性中显示出活性,并且符合疗效的先验假设;然而,尚不清楚这种反应是由于自然消退还是治疗效果。靶向HPV 16 E7癌蛋白的HspE7在感染16型以外HPV类型的患者中也有疗效,提示存在交叉反应性。需要进行更大规模的随机对照试验,以更好地确定疗效,并识别最可能从免疫治疗中获益的女性亚组。