Savage Robert, Carless Sue, Ferraro Vittoria
Faculty of Education, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2007 Jul;48(7):732-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2007.01746.x.
Phonological awareness tests are amongst the best predictors of literacy and predict outcomes of Key Stage 1 assessment of the National Curriculum in England at age 7. However, it is unknown whether their ability to predict National Curricular outcomes extends to Key Stage 2 assessments given at age 11, or also whether the predictive power of such tests is independent of letter-knowledge. We explored the unique predictive validity of phonological awareness and early literacy measures, and other pupil background measures taken at age 5 in the prediction of English, Maths, and Science performance at age 11.
Three hundred and eighty-two children from 21 primary schools in one Local Educational Authority were assessed at age 5 and followed to age 11 (Key Stage 2 assessment). Teaching assistants (TAs) administered phonological awareness tasks and early literacy measures. Baseline and Key Stage 2 performance measures were collected by teachers.
Phonological awareness was a significant unique predictor of all nine outcome measures after baseline assessment and pupil background measures were first controlled in regression analyses, and continued to be a significant predictor of reading, maths, and science performance, and teacher assessments after early literacy skill and letter-knowledge was controlled. Gender predicted performance in writing, the English test, and English teacher assessment, with girls outperforming boys.
Phonological awareness is a unique predictor of general curricular attainment independent of pupil background, early reading ability and letter-knowledge. Practically, screening of phonological awareness and basic reading skills by school staff in year 1 significantly enhances the capacity of schools to predict curricular outcomes in year 6.
语音意识测试是读写能力的最佳预测指标之一,能够预测英国国家课程在7岁时进行的关键阶段1评估的结果。然而,尚不清楚它们预测国家课程结果的能力是否延伸至11岁时进行的关键阶段2评估,也不清楚此类测试的预测能力是否独立于字母知识。我们探讨了语音意识和早期读写能力测量以及在5岁时获取的其他学生背景测量在预测11岁时英语、数学和科学成绩方面的独特预测效度。
对来自一个地方教育当局21所小学的382名儿童在5岁时进行评估,并跟踪至11岁(关键阶段2评估)。教学助理执行语音意识任务和早期读写能力测量。教师收集基线和关键阶段2的成绩测量数据。
在回归分析中首先控制基线评估和学生背景测量后,语音意识是所有九项结果测量的显著独特预测指标,在控制早期读写技能和字母知识后,它仍然是阅读、数学和科学成绩以及教师评估的显著预测指标。性别预测写作、英语测试和英语教师评估中的成绩,女孩表现优于男孩。
语音意识是独立于学生背景、早期阅读能力和字母知识的一般课程成绩的独特预测指标。实际上,一年级学校工作人员对语音意识和基本阅读技能进行筛查,可显著提高学校预测六年级课程结果的能力。