Penciner Rick, Siddiqui Sanam, Lee Shirley
North York General Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Acad Emerg Med. 2007 Aug;14(8):727-31. doi: 10.1197/j.aem.2007.04.013. Epub 2007 Jun 29.
Tracking medical student clinical encounters is now an accreditation requirement of medical schools. The use of handheld computers for electronic logging is emerging as a strategy to achieve this.
To evaluate the technical feasibility and student satisfaction of a novel electronic logging and feedback program using handheld computers in the emergency department.
This was a survey study of fourth-year medical student satisfaction with the use of their handheld computers for electronic logging of patient encounters and procedures. The authors also included an analysis of this technology.
Forty-six students participated in this pilot project, logging a total of 2,930 encounters. Students used the logs an average of 7.6 shifts per rotation, logging an average of 8.3 patients per shift. Twenty-nine students (63%) responded to the survey. Students generally found it easy to complete each encounter (69%) and easy to synchronize their handheld computer with the central server (83%). However, half the students (49%) never viewed the feedback Web site and most (79%) never reviewed their logs with their preceptors. Overall, only 17% found the logging program beneficial as a learning tool.
Electronic logging by medical students during their emergency medicine clerkship has many potential benefits as a method to document clinical encounters and procedures performed. However, this study demonstrated poor compliance and dissatisfaction with the process. In order for electronic logging using handheld computers to be a beneficial educational tool for both learners and educators, obstacles to effective implementation need to be addressed.
追踪医学生的临床接触情况现已成为医学院校认证的一项要求。使用手持计算机进行电子记录正成为实现这一要求的一种策略。
评估在急诊科使用一种新型电子记录与反馈程序的技术可行性及学生满意度,该程序使用手持计算机。
这是一项关于四年级医学生对使用手持计算机进行患者接触及操作电子记录满意度的调查研究。作者还对这项技术进行了分析。
46名学生参与了这个试点项目,共记录了2930次接触情况。学生们每次轮转平均使用记录7.6个班次,每班平均记录8.3名患者。29名学生(63%)回复了调查问卷。学生们普遍觉得完成每次接触记录很容易(69%),且将手持计算机与中央服务器同步也很容易(83%)。然而,一半的学生(49%)从未查看过反馈网站,大多数学生(79%)从未与带教老师一起查看过他们的记录。总体而言,只有17%的学生认为记录程序作为一种学习工具是有益的。
医学生在急诊医学实习期间进行电子记录,作为记录临床接触及所执行操作的一种方法有诸多潜在益处。然而,本研究表明在这个过程中依从性差且学生不满意。为了使使用手持计算机的电子记录成为对学习者和教育者都有益的教育工具,需要解决有效实施过程中的障碍。