Hemmingsson Tomas, Kriebel David, Tynelius Per, Rasmussen Finn, Lundberg Ingvar
Division of Occupational Health, Department of Public Health Sciences, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Eur J Public Health. 2008 Feb;18(1):66-70. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckm079. Epub 2007 Jul 12.
Several studies have reported an association between cigarette smoking and psychiatric illness. A common finding is that the prevalence of psychiatric illness among former smokers is much lower than among current smokers and is often similar to that among never-smokers. There are two alternative causal explanations for this association: either improved mental well-being results from smoking cessation; or those with poorer mental well-being are less successful at smoking cessation. The objective was to analyse a unique longitudinal data set to shed light on the direction of causality and to distinguish between these alternative explanations.
Information on smoking status and indicators of poor mental well-being from childhood and adolescence was collected at age 18 in 1969 from 49 321 men at compulsory conscription for military service. Follow-up data on smoking status were collected among a random subset (n = 694) who participated in one or more annual national Swedish Surveys of Living Conditions in 1981-2001.
Approximately half of the smokers at age 18 in 1969 had quit by the time they were resurveyed (1981-2002). Those who had not quit and who reported smoking more than 10 cigarettes/day at age 18 (called persistent heavy smokers), were more likely to have had childhood and adolescent indicators of poor mental health measured at age 18 in 1969 than non-smokers or quitters.
Our findings indicate that men who would subsequently be successful at smoking cessation reported better mental health and a lower prevalence of childhood mental health indicators at age 18 than persistent heavy smokers.
多项研究报告了吸烟与精神疾病之间的关联。一个常见的发现是,既往吸烟者中精神疾病的患病率远低于当前吸烟者,且往往与从不吸烟者相似。对于这种关联有两种互为因果的解释:要么戒烟能改善心理健康;要么心理健康状况较差的人戒烟更难成功。目的是分析一组独特的纵向数据集,以阐明因果关系的方向,并区分这些互为因果的解释。
1969年,在18岁义务兵役登记时,收集了49321名男性关于吸烟状况以及童年和青少年时期心理健康不佳指标的信息。在随机抽取的一个子集(n = 694)中收集了1981 - 2001年参与一项或多项瑞典全国年度生活状况调查的吸烟状况随访数据。
1969年18岁时的吸烟者中,约有一半在重新调查时(1981 - 2002年)已经戒烟。那些未戒烟且在18岁时报告每天吸烟超过10支的人(称为持续重度吸烟者),在1969年18岁时,比起非吸烟者或已戒烟者,更有可能有童年和青少年时期心理健康不佳的指标。
我们的研究结果表明,与持续重度吸烟者相比,那些后来成功戒烟的男性在18岁时心理健康状况更好,童年心理健康指标的患病率更低。