Lundström Corinne, Kytzia Susanne, Walz Ariane, Gret-Regamey Adrienne, Bebi Peter
Research Unit Ecosystem Boundaries, WSL: Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research, CH-7260 Davos, Switzerland.
Environ Manage. 2007 Sep;40(3):379-93. doi: 10.1007/s00267-005-0342-8. Epub 2007 Jul 18.
We present a framework of a scenario-based model that simulates the development of the municipality of Davos (Swiss Alps). We illustrate our method with the calculation of the scenario for 2050 "Decrease in subsidies for mountain agriculture and liberalization of markets." The main objective was to link submodels of land-use allocation (regression-based approach), material and energy flows submodels (Material and Energy Flux Analysis), and economic submodels (Input-Output Analysis). Letting qualitative and quantitative information flow from one submodel to the next, following the storyline describing a scenario, has proven to be suitable for linking submodels. The succession of the submodels is then strongly dependent on the scenario. Qualitative information flows are simulated with microsimulations of actor choices. Links between the submodels show different degrees of robustness: although the links involving microsimulations are the weakest, the uncertainty introduced by the land-use allocation model is actually advantageous because it allows one possible change in the landscape in the future to be simulated. The modeling results for the scenario here presented show that the disappearance of agriculture only marginally affects the region's factor income, but that the consequences for the self-sufficiency rate, for various landscape-related indicators and ecosystem services, and for the economy in the long term may be considerable. These benefits compensate for agriculture's modest direct economic value. The framework presented can potentially be applied to any region and scenario. This framework provides a basis for a learning package that allows potential detrimental consequences of regional development to be anticipated at an early stage.
我们提出了一个基于情景的模型框架,用于模拟达沃斯市(瑞士阿尔卑斯山区)的发展情况。我们通过计算2050年“山区农业补贴减少和市场自由化”情景来说明我们的方法。主要目标是将土地利用分配子模型(基于回归的方法)、物质和能量流子模型(物质与能量通量分析)以及经济子模型(投入产出分析)联系起来。事实证明,让定性和定量信息按照描述情景的故事情节从一个子模型流向另一个子模型,适用于子模型的链接。子模型的顺序随后强烈依赖于情景。定性信息流通过行为者选择的微观模拟来模拟。子模型之间的链接显示出不同程度的稳健性:尽管涉及微观模拟的链接最薄弱,但土地利用分配模型引入的不确定性实际上是有利的,因为它允许模拟未来景观中一种可能发生的变化。此处呈现的情景建模结果表明,农业的消失对该地区要素收入的影响微乎其微,但从长期来看,对自给率、各种与景观相关的指标和生态系统服务以及经济的影响可能相当大。这些益处弥补了农业适度的直接经济价值。所提出的框架有可能应用于任何地区和情景。该框架为一个学习包提供了基础,使人们能够在早期阶段预见到区域发展可能产生的有害后果。