Niewiadomski W, Gasiorowska A, Krauss B, Mróz A, Cybulski G
Department of Applied Physiology, Medical Research Center, Polish Academy of Sciences, 5 Pawinski Street, 02-106 Warsaw, Poland.
Clin Physiol Funct Imaging. 2007 Sep;27(5):309-19. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-097X.2007.00753.x.
Wingate test is short anaerobic exercise, performed with maximal power, whereas aerobic exercise at 85% maximal heart rate (HR(max)) may be performed for long period. Sustained HR elevations and changes in autonomic activity indices have been observed after latter kind of exercise. Several studies reported reduction in mean interval between consecutive R peaks in ECG (RRI) 1 h after Wingate test; however, underlying changes in autonomic activity remain elusive. In eight young males, RRI and heart rate variability (HRV) were measured daily over two 5-day trials. Subjects exercised on third day of each trial, measurements were taken 1 h after (i) two consecutive 30-s bouts of Wingate tests or (ii) after a 30-min exercise at 85% HR(max), with subjects in supine rest and breathing either spontaneously or at controlled rates of 6 and 15 breaths / min. RRI was significantly shorter after Wingate and submaximal exercise, reduction of high- and low-frequency components of HRV attained reliability only after Wingate tests. This pattern remained preserved for three modes of breathing: spontaneous, 6 and 15 breaths /min. After 24 and 48 h, no exercise effects were traceable. We hypothesize that (i) anaerobic exertion is followed by sustained inhibition of vagal activity, (ii) parasympathetic system plays dominant role in mediating suppression of high- and low-HRV frequency components during postexercise recovery, (iii) degree of alteration of autonomic activity caused by anaerobic and strenuous aerobic exercise may be similar and (iv) normalization of vagal activity precedes normalization of sympathetic cardiac nerves activity during final stage of postexercise recovery.
温盖特测试是一种短时间的无氧运动,以最大功率进行,而以最大心率(HR(max))的85%进行的有氧运动可以持续较长时间。在后一种运动后,观察到心率持续升高以及自主神经活动指标的变化。几项研究报告称,温盖特测试后1小时,心电图中连续R波峰之间的平均间隔(RRI)缩短;然而,自主神经活动的潜在变化仍然难以捉摸。在8名年轻男性中,在两个为期5天的试验中每天测量RRI和心率变异性(HRV)。受试者在每个试验的第三天进行运动,在(i)连续两次30秒的温盖特测试或(ii)在以85% HR(max)进行30分钟运动后1小时进行测量,受试者仰卧休息,以自发呼吸或6次和15次呼吸/分钟的控制速率呼吸。温盖特测试和次最大运动后RRI显著缩短,HRV的高频和低频成分的降低仅在温盖特测试后达到可靠性。这种模式在三种呼吸模式下均保持不变:自发呼吸、6次和15次呼吸/分钟。在24小时和48小时后,未发现运动效果。我们假设:(i)无氧运动后迷走神经活动持续受到抑制;(ii)副交感神经系统在运动后恢复期间介导高HRV和低HRV频率成分抑制中起主导作用;(iii)无氧运动和剧烈有氧运动引起的自主神经活动改变程度可能相似;(iv)在运动后恢复的最后阶段,迷走神经活动的正常化先于交感心脏神经活动的正常化。