McPhail Beverly A, Busch Noël Bridget, Kulkarni Shanti, Rice Gail
University of Houston, TX, USA.
Violence Against Women. 2007 Aug;13(8):817-41. doi: 10.1177/1077801207302039.
The feminist perspective on intimate partner violence is a predominant model in the field, although not immune to criticism. In this research, frontline workers in the violence against women movement responded to critiques of the feminist model. The project used a focus group and a modified grounded theory analysis. Participants agreed with some criticisms, including an overreliance on a punitive criminal justice system, but reported skepticism toward proposed alternatives. Findings led to the development of the Integrative Feminist Model, which expands the feminist perspective in response to critiques, new research, and alternative theories while retaining a gendered analysis of violence.
尽管并非不受批评,但女性主义视角下的亲密伴侣暴力是该领域的主导模式。在这项研究中,妇女暴力运动的一线工作者回应了对女性主义模式的批评。该项目采用了焦点小组和改良的扎根理论分析方法。参与者认同一些批评意见,包括过度依赖惩罚性刑事司法系统,但对提出的替代方案表示怀疑。研究结果促成了综合女性主义模式的发展,该模式在回应批评、新研究和替代理论的同时,扩展了女性主义视角,同时保留了对暴力的性别分析。