Seim Andreas R, Dahl Douglas M, Sandberg Warren S
Department of Production and Quality Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
J Endourol. 2007 Jul;21(7):703-8. doi: 10.1089/end.2007.0030.
Operating room throughput is influenced by the efficiency of the perioperative process (for nonoperative time) and by the surgeon (for operative time). Operative time is thought not to be easily amenable to deliberate reductions. We tested the hypothesis that gradual improvements in operative time had allowed one surgeon to perform additional cases during scheduled hours.
The surgeon had been working in both a high-throughput and a conventional operating room for more than 1 year prior to the study. During the studied interval, we applied statistical process control analysis to time data for the surgeon performing full days of complex laparoscopic operations. Separate analyses were conducted for the conventional and high-throughput operating rooms. The average operative time for each day and the number of cases per day were plotted against sequential days for each environment.
Midway through the studied interval, there was a discrete 17-minute drop in operative time in both the high-throughput and the conventional environment. Throughput increased from two cases per day to three per day in the high-throughput environment. The average end time for the three-case days was 17:15 (range 16:04-18:32). Longer average operative and nonoperative times in the conventional rooms precluded performing three complex cases during regular work hours.
There was a sudden, rather than a gradual, reduction of operative time leading to extra cases being performed. This coincided with (1) the surgeon being assigned a new fellow and (2) administrative commitment to finish three cases per day. Our original hypothesis was negated, but other controllable causes for changes in surgical throughput were identified.
手术室效率受围手术期流程效率(非手术时间)和外科医生(手术时间)的影响。一般认为手术时间难以通过刻意缩短来改善。我们检验了这样一个假设,即手术时间的逐步改善使一位外科医生能够在预定时间内完成更多手术。
在研究开始前,该外科医生已在高流量手术室和传统手术室工作超过1年。在研究期间,我们对该外科医生进行整日复杂腹腔镜手术的时间数据应用统计过程控制分析。分别对传统手术室和高流量手术室进行分析。针对每个环境,将每天的平均手术时间和每天的手术例数与连续天数进行绘图。
在研究期间的中途,高流量手术室和传统手术室的手术时间均出现了17分钟的明显下降。在高流量手术室,手术量从每天两例增加到每天三例。三例手术日的平均结束时间为17:15(范围为16:04 - 18:32)。传统手术室较长的平均手术时间和非手术时间使得在正常工作时间内无法完成三台复杂手术。
手术时间出现了突然而非逐步的减少,从而能够完成额外的手术。这与以下两点同时发生:(1)该外科医生被分配了一名新助手;(2)行政部门承诺每天完成三台手术。我们最初的假设被否定,但确定了手术效率变化的其他可控原因。