Niebudek-Bogusz Ewa, Kotyło Piotr, Sliwińska-Kowalska Mariola
Clinic of Audiology and Phoniatrics, Nofer Institute of Occupational Medicine, św. Teresy 8, 91-348 Łódź, Poland.
Int J Occup Med Environ Health. 2007;20(1):25-30. doi: 10.2478/v10001-007-0001-9.
Teachers are at risk of developing voice disorders. A clinical battery of vocal function tests should include non-invasive and accurate measurements. The quantitative methods (e.g., voice acoustic analysis) make it possible to objectively evaluate voice efficiency and outcomes of dysphonia treatment.
To identify possible signs of vocal fatigue, acoustic waveform perturbations during sustained phonation were measured before and after the vocal-loading test in 51 professionally active female teachers with functional voice disorders, using IRIS software. All the participants were also subjected to laryngological/phoniatric examination involving videostroboscopy combined with self-estimation by voice handicap index (VHI)-based scale.
The phoniatric examination revealed glottal insufficiency with bowed vocal folds in 35.2%, soft vocal nodules in 31.4%, and hyperfunctional dysphonia with a tendency towards vestibular phonation in 19.6% of the patients. In the VHI scale, 66% of the female teachers estimated their own voice problems as moderate disability. An acoustic analysis performed after the vocal-loading test showed an increased rate of abnormal frequency perturbation parameters (pitch perturbation quotient (Jitter), relative average perturbation (RAP), and pitch period perturbation quotient (PPQ)) compared to the pre-test outcomes. The same was true of pitch-intensity contour of vowel /a:/, an indication of voice instability during sustained phonation.
The recorded impairments of voice acoustic parameters related to vocal loading provide further evidence of dysphonia. The voice acoustic analysis performed before and after the vocal-loading test can significantly contribute to objective voice examinations useful in diagnosis of dysphonia among teachers.
教师有患嗓音疾病的风险。一系列临床嗓音功能测试应包括非侵入性且准确的测量方法。定量方法(如嗓音声学分析)能够客观地评估嗓音效率和发声障碍治疗效果。
为识别嗓音疲劳的可能迹象,使用IRIS软件对51名患有功能性嗓音障碍的在职女教师在嗓音负荷测试前后的持续发声过程中的声学波形扰动进行了测量。所有参与者还接受了喉科学/发声治疗学检查,包括视频频闪喉镜检查以及基于嗓音障碍指数(VHI)量表的自我评估。
发声治疗学检查发现,35.2%的患者存在声门闭合不全伴声带弓形,31.4%的患者有软性声带小结,19.6%的患者有功能亢进性发声障碍且有前庭发声倾向。在VHI量表中,66%的女教师将自己的嗓音问题评估为中度残疾。嗓音负荷测试后进行的声学分析显示,与测试前结果相比,异常频率扰动参数(基频微扰商(Jitter)、相对平均扰动(RAP)和基周期微扰商(PPQ))的发生率增加。元音/a:/的音高-强度轮廓也是如此,这表明持续发声过程中嗓音不稳定。
记录的与嗓音负荷相关的嗓音声学参数损伤为发声障碍提供了进一步证据。在嗓音负荷测试前后进行的嗓音声学分析能够显著有助于客观的嗓音检查,对诊断教师中的发声障碍很有用。