Schloegl Christian, Kotrschal Kurt, Bugnyar Thomas
Konrad Lorenz-Forschungsstelle, Fischerau 11, 4645, Grünau im Almtal, Austria.
Anim Cogn. 2008 Apr;11(2):231-41. doi: 10.1007/s10071-007-0105-4. Epub 2007 Aug 31.
The ability of non-human animals to use experimenter-given cues in object-choice tasks has recently gained interest. In such experiments, the location of hidden food is indicated by an experimenter, e.g. by gazing, pointing or touching. Whereas dogs apparently outperform all other species so far tested, apes and monkeys have problems in using such cues. Since only mammalian species have been tested, information is lacking about the evolutionary origin of these abilities. We here present the first data on object-choice tasks conducted with an avian species, the common raven. Ravens are highly competitive scavengers, possessing sophisticated cognitive skills in protecting their food caches and pilfering others' caches. We conducted three experiments, exploring (i) which kind of cues ravens use for choosing a certain object, (ii) whether ravens use humans' gaze for detecting hidden food and (iii) whether ravens would find hidden food in the presence of an informed conspecific who potentially provides gaze cues. Our results indicate that ravens reliably respond to humans' touching of an object, but they hardly use point and gaze cues for their choices. Likewise, they do not perform above chance level in the presence of an informed conspecific. These findings mirror those obtained for primates and suggest that, although ravens may be aware of the gaze direction of humans and conspecifics, they apparently do not rely on this information to detect hidden food.
非人类动物在物体选择任务中利用实验者给出的线索的能力最近引起了人们的兴趣。在这类实验中,隐藏食物的位置由实验者指示,例如通过注视、指向或触摸。虽然到目前为止,狗在使用此类线索方面明显优于所有其他已测试的物种,但猿类和猴子在使用这些线索时存在困难。由于仅对哺乳动物物种进行了测试,因此缺乏关于这些能力进化起源的信息。我们在此展示了关于对一种鸟类——普通渡鸦进行物体选择任务的首批数据。渡鸦是极具竞争力的食腐动物,在保护自己的食物储藏以及偷取其他动物的储藏方面具备复杂的认知技能。我们进行了三项实验,探究(i)渡鸦使用哪种线索来选择某个物体,(ii)渡鸦是否利用人类的注视来探测隐藏食物,以及(iii)在有一个可能提供注视线索的知情同种个体在场的情况下,渡鸦是否能找到隐藏食物。我们的结果表明,渡鸦能可靠地对人类触摸物体做出反应,但它们在选择时几乎不使用指向和注视线索。同样,在有知情同种个体在场的情况下,它们的表现也未超过随机水平。这些发现与在灵长类动物身上得到的结果相似,表明尽管渡鸦可能意识到人类和同种个体的注视方向,但它们显然不依赖这些信息来探测隐藏食物。