Bravata Dena M, Wang Ewen, Holty Jon-Erik, Lewis Robyn, Wise Paul H, Nayak Smita, Liu Hau, McDonald Kathryn M, Owens Douglas K
Evid Rep Technol Assess (Full Rep). 2006 Aug(141):1-48.
To systematically review the literature about children with anthrax to describe their clinical course, treatment responses, and the predictors of disease progression and mortality.
MEDLINE (1966-2005), 14 selected journal indexes (1900-1966) and bibliographies of all retrieved articles.
We sought case reports of pediatric anthrax published between 1900 and 2005 meeting predefined criteria. We abstracted three types of data from the English-language reports: (1) Patient information (e.g., age, gender, nationality), (2) symptom and disease progression information (e.g., whether the patient developed meningitis); (3) treatment information (e.g., treatments received, year of treatment). We compared the clinical symptoms and disease progression variables for the pediatric cases with data on adult anthrax cases reviewed previously.
We identified 246 titles of potentially relevant articles from our MEDLINE(R) search and 2253 additional references from our manual search of the bibliographies of retrieved articles and the indexes of the 14 selected journals. We included 62 case reports of pediatric anthrax including two inhalational cases, 20 gastrointestinal cases, 37 cutaneous cases, and three atypical cases. Anthrax is a relatively common and historically well-recognized disease and yet rarely reported among children, suggesting the possibility of significant under-diagnosis, underreporting, and/or publication bias. Children with anthrax present with a wide range of clinical signs and symptoms, which differ somewhat from the presenting features of adults with anthrax. Like adults, children with gastrointestinal anthrax have two distinct clinical presentations: Upper tract disease characterized by dysphagia and oropharyngeal findings and lower tract disease characterized by fever, abdominal pain, and nausea and vomiting. Additionally, children with inhalational disease may have "atypical" presentations including primary meningoencephalitis. Children with inhalational anthrax have abnormal chest roentgenograms; however, children with other forms of anthrax usually have normal roentgenograms. Nineteen of the 30 children (63%) who received penicillin-based antibiotics survived; whereas nine of 11 children (82%) who received anthrax antiserum survived.
There is a broad spectrum of clinical signs and symptoms associated with pediatric anthrax. The limited data available regarding disease progression and treatment responses for children infected with anthrax suggest some differences from adult populations. Preparedness planning efforts should specifically address the needs of pediatric victims.
系统回顾关于儿童炭疽病的文献,以描述其临床病程、治疗反应以及疾病进展和死亡的预测因素。
MEDLINE(1966 - 2005年)、14种选定的期刊索引(1900 - 1966年)以及所有检索到文章的参考文献目录。
我们查找1900年至2005年间发表的符合预定义标准的儿童炭疽病病例报告。我们从英文报告中提取了三类数据:(1)患者信息(如年龄、性别、国籍);(2)症状和疾病进展信息(如患者是否发生脑膜炎);(3)治疗信息(如接受的治疗、治疗年份)。我们将儿童病例的临床症状和疾病进展变量与先前综述的成人炭疽病病例数据进行了比较。
通过对MEDLINE的检索,我们确定了246篇可能相关文章的标题,并通过手动检索检索到文章的参考文献目录和14种选定期刊的索引,又获得了2253条参考文献。我们纳入了62篇儿童炭疽病病例报告,其中包括2例吸入性病例、20例胃肠道病例、37例皮肤病例和3例非典型病例。炭疽病是一种相对常见且历史上广为人知的疾病,但在儿童中却很少有报道,这表明可能存在严重的漏诊、漏报和/或发表偏倚。患炭疽病的儿童表现出广泛的临床体征和症状,与患炭疽病的成人的表现特征略有不同。与成人一样,患胃肠道炭疽病的儿童有两种不同的临床表现:以上消化道疾病表现为吞咽困难和口咽部症状,下消化道疾病表现为发热、腹痛、恶心和呕吐。此外,患吸入性疾病的儿童可能有“非典型”表现,包括原发性脑膜脑炎。患吸入性炭疽病的儿童胸部X线片异常;然而,患其他形式炭疽病的儿童X线片通常正常。接受基于青霉素的抗生素治疗的30名儿童中有19名(63%)存活;而接受炭疽抗血清治疗的11名儿童中有9名(82%)存活。
儿童炭疽病有广泛的临床体征和症状。关于感染炭疽病儿童的疾病进展和治疗反应的现有数据有限,这表明与成人人群存在一些差异。应急准备规划工作应特别关注儿童受害者的需求。