Bestwick Charles S, Milne Lesley, Duthie Susan J
Molecular Nutrition Group, Rowett Research Institute, Greenburn Road, Bucksburn, Aberdeen AB21 9SB, UK.
Chem Biol Interact. 2007 Nov 20;170(2):76-85. doi: 10.1016/j.cbi.2007.07.002. Epub 2007 Jul 18.
Dietary flavonoids may be exploitable as chemotherapeutics and preventatives for critical health conditions, including cancer. Antiproliferative effects are commonly ascribed to such compounds but ambiguity exists as to the principal mechanism of action and the universal benefit of exposure, particularly at high concentrations. Here, we identify heterogeneous responses within HL-60 promyelocytic leukaemia cells that explain contradictions in the reported origin of the antiproliferative action of kaempferol, a dietary abundant flavonoid. At > or =10 microM, kaempferol exposure is predominantly characterised by cell cycle alterations, notably a significant increase in S-phase and a progressive accumulation in G2-M with 10 and > or =20 microM kaempferol, respectively. However, a limited but consistent membrane damage is observed across the 1-100 microM exposure and at 1 microM occurs devoid from indices of apoptosis which are only consistently observed with > or =10 microM kaempferol treatment. At the most cytotoxic exposures, multiparametric flow cytometric analysis revealed distinct sub populations of cells. Cells with decreased size, typical of apoptosis and necrosis, possessed heightened caspase-3 activity, decreased anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 expression and changes to membrane asymmetry and integrity. The remaining population had elevated active caspase-3 but no change or a moderate increase in Bcl-2 expression and no plasma membrane alterations. Differentiation was not a significant factor in HL-60 growth inhibition. In conclusion, kaempferol-induced growth inhibition is dominated by cell cycle changes but involves a limited cytotoxicity, which we propose results from a membrane damage centred as well as an apoptotic process. This heterogeneity of response may confound the disease-preventative role and pharmacological application of this flavonoid.
膳食类黄酮可作为化疗药物和预防严重健康问题(包括癌症)的药物。此类化合物通常具有抗增殖作用,但关于其主要作用机制以及暴露(尤其是高浓度暴露)的普遍益处仍存在模糊性。在此,我们在HL-60早幼粒细胞白血病细胞中发现了异质性反应,这解释了山奈酚(一种膳食中丰富的类黄酮)抗增殖作用的报道来源中的矛盾之处。在≥10微摩尔时,山奈酚暴露主要表现为细胞周期改变,尤其是S期显著增加,分别用10微摩尔和≥20微摩尔山奈酚处理时,G2-M期逐渐积累。然而,在1-100微摩尔暴露范围内均观察到有限但一致的膜损伤,在1微摩尔时出现膜损伤但无凋亡指标,而凋亡指标仅在≥10微摩尔山奈酚处理时持续观察到。在细胞毒性最大的暴露条件下,多参数流式细胞术分析揭示了不同的细胞亚群。细胞大小减小,典型的凋亡和坏死特征,具有增强的半胱天冬酶-3活性,抗凋亡Bcl-2表达降低以及膜不对称性和完整性改变。其余细胞群的活性半胱天冬酶-3升高,但Bcl-2表达无变化或适度增加,且质膜无改变。分化不是HL-60生长抑制的重要因素。总之,山奈酚诱导的生长抑制主要由细胞周期变化主导,但涉及有限的细胞毒性,我们认为这是由以膜损伤为中心以及凋亡过程导致的。这种反应的异质性可能会混淆这种类黄酮的疾病预防作用和药理学应用。