Endrass Jérôme, Rossegger Astrid, Noll Thomas, Urbaniok Frank
Psychiatrisch-Psychologischer Dienst, Justizvollzug des Kantons Zürich, Zürich, Schweiz.
Psychiatr Prax. 2008 Jan;35(1):8-14. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-970962. Epub 2007 Sep 5.
In recent years, the offense preventive effect of forensic therapy has been the subject of controversial debate. In this review, the current state of therapy evaluation research in forensics is discussed, with special consideration of methodological aspects.
Systematic research of literature on studies that analyse the risk-reducing effect of offender therapies.
The study designs are very heterogeneous and results are thus difficult to compare. Furthermore, there are only a few empirical studies on the relapse prevention efficiency of forensic therapies.
Due to the methodological diversity of the studies, a concluding evaluation of the efficiency of forensic psychotherapies is not possible. The conclusions drawn from meta-analyses must thus be interpreted with great care.
近年来,法医治疗的犯罪预防效果一直是备受争议的话题。在本综述中,我们讨论了法医领域治疗评估研究的现状,并特别考虑了方法学方面的问题。
对分析罪犯治疗降低风险效果的研究文献进行系统检索。
研究设计非常多样化,因此结果难以比较。此外,关于法医治疗预防复发效果的实证研究很少。
由于研究方法的多样性,无法对法医心理治疗的效果进行总结性评估。因此,对荟萃分析得出的结论必须谨慎解读。