Science. 1967 Sep 29;157(3796):1530-3. doi: 10.1126/science.157.3796.1530.
The situation of graduate students in physics is profoundly influenced by federal support, which has been applied with mixed, and occasionally contradictory, purpose. There are five important goals in the provision of graduate student stipends: (i) maintenance of "distinction for excellence"; (ii) rational distribution over scientific fields and subfields; (iii) constructive involvement of graduate students in undergraduate teaching; (iv) rational geographic and institutional distribution; and (v) administrative simplicity. These goals may be approached by making several adjustments of the present system. 1) The preeminence of individual predoctoral fellowships should be restored. They should be awarded sparingly to at most five percent of the graduate student population. 2) The great majority of stipends should take the form of traineeships. They should be assigned to departments according to rational criteria. 3) Research assistantships should be continued at a reduced level. Their maintenance will protect research activities of specific public interest when necessary. 4) Teaching should be incorporated into the normal responsibilities of fellows, trainees, and research assistants. Teaching assistance should be regarded as a budgeting category and not as an identifying characteristic of a particular group of students.
研究生在物理学领域的状况受到联邦政府支持的深刻影响,这些支持的目的既有混合的,也有相互矛盾的。研究生助学金的发放有五个重要目标:(i)保持“卓越的卓越性”;(ii)在科学领域和子领域中进行合理分配;(iii)让研究生建设性地参与本科教学;(iv)合理的地理和机构分布;以及(v)管理简单化。可以通过对现有制度进行若干调整来实现这些目标。1)应恢复个人博士前奖学金的卓越地位。它们应该很少授予,最多授予研究生总数的 5%。2)绝大多数助学金应采用培训生的形式。它们应根据合理标准分配给各个部门。3)研究助理职位应继续减少。当需要时,它们的维持将保护特定公共利益的研究活动。4)教学应纳入研究员、培训生和研究助理的正常职责。教学援助应被视为预算类别,而不是特定学生群体的特征。