Byrne R W, Byrne J M
Department of Psychology, University of St. Andrews, Scotland.
Cortex. 1991 Dec;27(4):521-46. doi: 10.1016/s0010-9452(13)80003-2.
Manual dexterity of 44 wild gorillas of all ages and both sexes was investigated on six naturally acquired feeding tasks of varied logical structure, which included multi-stage and bimanually coordinated procedures. At least 400 min observation of feeding per animal, and analysis at the level of bouts rather than individual actions, can be expected to produce statistically robust results; 22 years background data allowed effects of genealogy and injury to be investigated. Five tasks elicited very strong hand preferences in most animals (weakest on the simplest task), while one was usually performed with a strategy in which left and right hands were used symmetrically; the preferences were fully established at 3 years old. Preferences were highly correlated within each of two sets of tasks, but between the two sets there was no correlation across animals in direction or strength of preference. No population trends towards left or right handers were found in either set of tasks, or both sets pooled; distributions were U-shaped and approximately symmetric, with a slight bias towards right-handed fine manipulation in one set of tasks. Processing efficiency was only slightly greater with the preferred hand, and similar in left- and right-handed animals. Neither direction nor strength of hand preference showed a tendency to run in families, but females showed greater strength of preference. Major injury masked strong hand preference, but injuries could not account for the overall distribution of preference; instead this may reflect inbreeding. Feedback acting on initially random hand choices, and imitation at the "program" level rather than slavish copying of acts, are proposed to account for the results.
对44只不同年龄和性别的野生大猩猩的手部灵活性进行了研究,研究内容为六项自然习得的、逻辑结构各异的进食任务,其中包括多阶段和双手协调的操作。预计每只动物至少有400分钟的进食观察时间,且分析以进食回合而非单个动作的层面进行,这样才能得出统计学上可靠的结果;22年的背景数据有助于研究谱系和受伤情况的影响。五项任务在大多数动物中引发了非常强烈的用手偏好(在最简单的任务中偏好最弱),而另一项任务通常采用左右对称使用双手的策略;这些偏好到3岁时已完全确立。偏好在两组任务中的每一组内都高度相关,但在两组任务之间,动物在偏好方向或强度上没有相关性。在任何一组任务中,或两组任务合并后,都未发现左撇子或右撇子的群体趋势;分布呈U形且大致对称,在一组任务中对右手精细操作略有偏向。使用偏好手时的处理效率仅略高,且在左撇子和右撇子动物中相似。用手偏好的方向和强度在家族中均未表现出遗传倾向,但雌性的偏好强度更大。严重受伤掩盖了强烈的用手偏好,但受伤并不能解释偏好的总体分布;相反,这可能反映了近亲繁殖。研究结果表明,最初随机的用手选择受到了反馈影响,且是在“程序”层面的模仿而非对动作的盲目复制。