Ten Kate C A, Eurelings-Bontekoe E H M, Muller N, Spinhoven Ph
GGZ Duinen Bollenstreek Volwassenzorg, Postbus 3, 2215 ZG Voorhout, Netherlands.
Tijdschr Psychiatr. 2007;49(9):597-609.
Personality disorders occur frequently. The presence of one or more personality disorders can influence the severity of the symptoms and can affect coping, treatment indication and drop out.
To study the prevalence of personality disorders in an ambulatory health care centre and to investigate the influence of both the severity and the nature of personality disorders on the following: symptomatology, interpersonal behaviour, coping and defence mechanisms, personality traits, treatment indication and drop out.
We studied the prevalence of personality disorders in 100 patients using the International Personality Disorder Examination (IPDE), a semi-structured interview. Symptoms, interpersonal behaviour, coping and defence mechanisms and personality traits were assessed by means of self-reports. Patients were assigned to specific types of treatment by their own doctors, who were not aware of the assessment results. results Most of the patients suffered from a personality disorder. Patients with cluster-A-type personality disorders were all assigned to treatment. The majority of patients with cluster- B-type personality disorders were assigned to Axis-ii-type treatment but most patients with cluster-A-and cluster-C personality disorders were assigned to Axis-I-type treatment. The dropout percentage was higher among patients with a personality disorder than among those without. Among patients with personality disorders the drop-out percentage was highest in those from the A and C clusters. Patients with personality pathology from the A cluster were 13 times more likely to drop out than those without A cluster pathology, patients with C cluster pathology were 11 times more likely to drop out than those without C cluster pathology.
In ambulatory mental health care more attention needs to be given to the diagnosis of personality disorders. Results suggest that in the treatment of patients with A and C cluster pathology much effort must be directed at fostering therapeutic alliance and compliance to treatment.
人格障碍频繁发生。一种或多种人格障碍的存在会影响症状的严重程度,并会影响应对方式、治疗指征及脱落情况。
研究门诊医疗中心人格障碍的患病率,并调查人格障碍的严重程度和性质对以下方面的影响:症状学、人际行为、应对和防御机制、人格特质、治疗指征及脱落情况。
我们使用国际人格障碍检查表(IPDE)这一半结构化访谈,研究了100例患者的人格障碍患病率。通过自我报告评估症状、人际行为、应对和防御机制以及人格特质。患者由其自己的医生分配到特定类型的治疗中,这些医生不知道评估结果。结果大多数患者患有某种人格障碍。患有A类人格障碍的患者均被分配接受治疗。大多数B类人格障碍患者被分配接受第二轴型治疗,但大多数A类和C类人格障碍患者被分配接受第一轴型治疗。有人格障碍的患者的脱落率高于没有人格障碍的患者。在有人格障碍的患者中,A类和C类患者的脱落率最高。患有A类人格病理的患者脱落的可能性是没有A类病理的患者的13倍,患有C类病理的患者脱落的可能性是没有C类病理的患者的11倍。
在门诊心理健康护理中,需要更加关注人格障碍的诊断。结果表明,在治疗患有A类和C类病理的患者时,必须付出很大努力来促进治疗联盟和治疗依从性。