Ueno Chiho, Oda Hiroyuki, Inoue Masaharu, Ariki Nagako, Hasaba Miho, Kinoshita Toshihiko
Department of Neuropsychiatry, Kansai Medical University.
Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi. 2007;109(7):637-53.
Paraphilia refers to occasional concomitant disorders of pervasive developmental disorder (PDD). When a restricted interest of PDD is focused on a sexual object, paraphilia may be develop as a problematic symptom. However, having this concomitant disorder does not always result in criminal behavior. When the social interactivity of a particular patient with PDD is severely impaired, paraphilia could lead to a sex crime. Because pedophilia targets sacrifice innocent and defenseless children, it is critical to prevent such sex crimes by understanding the psychopathology of PDD with paraphilia, especially pedophilia. Two cases of male adolescents with high-functioning PDD and pedophilia were reported; one ended up committing a serious crime, and the other controlled his sexual impulse. The psychopathology of these two cases was similar; however, the outcome turned out to be quite different. The similarity and dissimilarity of these two cases were analyzed. We came to a conclusion that early intervention could be a key to prevent the development of criminal sexual behavior in PDD with paraphilia (pedophilia). Both patients became aware of pedophilia during adolescence and developed a depressive state at the time of consulting our clinic. In the first case, the patient stabbed a woman with a knife. He could not respect other people, including women he was sexually interested in and has always been preoccupied with his own peculiar ideas. He did not listen to other people's opinions and his abnormal thoughts had never been corrected because of his lack of ability to form interpersonal relationships. The second patient could control his sexual impulse. He has an ability to sympathize with the child he is sexually interested in and has confronted his sexual impulses. He could build interpersonal relationship with others and listen to other people's opinions. He made an effort to manage his sexual impulses positively through individual psychotherapy. He was diagnosed at the age of two years and started rehabilitation training soon after. He had some experiences of consulting people when he was in trouble. In the treatment and correctional education of pedophilia, some sort of special care regarding the characteristics of PDD is indispensable; e.g., pointing-out and explaining unacceptable behavior repeatedly, teaching the correct action concretely, and changing the pathological sexual preference into a constructive one, etc. These therapeutic approaches are quite different from controlling paraphilia without PDD. PDD adolescents with impaired social interactivity could be further helper if they are diagnosed at an earlier stage of their lives and managed appropriately. A sense of being accepted by others and also experiences of mutual interaction with others are particularly important for them. Professionals should be aware that an early and proper intervention method could prevent the later development of criminal behavior in PDD adolescents who suffer from a sense of incompatibility with others because of concomitant paraphilia.
性偏好障碍是指广泛性发育障碍(PDD)偶尔伴发的病症。当PDD的一种受限兴趣聚焦于一个性对象时,性偏好障碍可能会发展成为一个问题症状。然而,患有这种伴发病症并不一定会导致犯罪行为。当患有PDD的特定患者的社交互动严重受损时,性偏好障碍可能会导致性犯罪。由于恋童癖的目标是无辜且毫无防备的儿童,通过了解伴有性偏好障碍(尤其是恋童癖)的PDD的精神病理学来预防此类性犯罪至关重要。报告了两例患有高功能PDD和恋童癖的男性青少年病例;一例最终犯下严重罪行,另一例则控制住了自己的性冲动。这两个病例的精神病理学相似;然而,结果却大不相同。分析了这两个病例的异同。我们得出结论,早期干预可能是预防伴有性偏好障碍(恋童癖)的PDD患者发展出性犯罪行为的关键。两名患者在青春期都意识到了恋童癖,并在前来我们诊所咨询时出现了抑郁状态。在第一个病例中,患者用刀刺伤了一名女性。他不尊重他人,包括他对其有性兴趣的女性,并且一直沉迷于自己的奇特想法。他不听从他人的意见,由于缺乏建立人际关系的能力,他的异常想法从未得到纠正。第二个患者能够控制自己的性冲动。他有能力同情他对其有性兴趣的儿童,并直面自己的性冲动。他能够与他人建立人际关系并听取他人的意见。他通过个体心理治疗积极努力地管理自己的性冲动。他在两岁时被诊断出患有疾病,并在不久后开始接受康复训练。他在遇到麻烦时有向他人咨询的经历。在恋童癖的治疗和矫正教育中,针对PDD的特征采取某种特殊护理是必不可少的;例如,反复指出并解释不可接受的行为,具体教授正确的行为,并将病理性的性偏好转变为建设性的性偏好等。这些治疗方法与控制不伴有PDD的性偏好障碍有很大不同。社交互动受损的PDD青少年如果在生命早期被诊断出来并得到适当管理,可能会得到进一步的帮助。被他人接受的感觉以及与他人相互交往的经历对他们尤为重要。专业人员应该意识到,一种早期且适当的干预方法可以预防患有伴有性偏好障碍而与他人存在不兼容感的PDD青少年日后发展出犯罪行为。