Schmidt Winsor C, Akinci Fevzi, Wagner Sarah A
Department of Health Policy and Administration, Washington State University, Spokane, WA 99210-1495, USA.
Behav Sci Law. 2007;25(5):641-53. doi: 10.1002/bsl.782.
This study investigated the relationship between guardian certification requirements and guardian sanctioning in the state of Washington. A total of 377 files were examined. Findings show that 52.4% of guardians with an undergraduate degree or higher education are likely to be sanctioned compared with 42.2% with an Associate of Arts (AA) or Technical (Tech) degree, and 36.9% with a high school diploma (HS) or equivalency (GED). Guardians with an undergraduate or higher education are 1.88 times more likely to be sanctioned compared with GED or HS graduates (p < 0.05). However, 83.3% of GED or HS graduates are likely to have more severe sanctions compared with 76.4% undergraduate or higher education, and 47.7% with an AA or Tech degree, respectively. Guardians with an AA or Tech degree are 0.28 times less likely to have more severe sanctions than guardians with an undergraduate degree or higher education (p < 0.01). The results are discussed with respect to guardian registration, licensing, certification and quality; licensing and regulation of other professions; the limitations of the study; and the need for further research.
本研究调查了华盛顿州监护人认证要求与监护人制裁之间的关系。共检查了377份档案。研究结果表明,拥有本科学历或更高学历的监护人中有52.4%可能受到制裁,相比之下,拥有文学副学士学位(AA)或技术学位(Tech)的监护人这一比例为42.2%,拥有高中文凭(HS)或同等学历(GED)的监护人这一比例为36.9%。拥有本科学历或更高学历的监护人受到制裁的可能性是拥有GED或HS文凭毕业生的1.88倍(p < 0.05)。然而,拥有GED或HS文凭的毕业生中,83.3%可能受到更严厉的制裁,相比之下,拥有本科学历或更高学历的监护人为76.4%,拥有AA或Tech学位的监护人为47.7%。拥有AA或Tech学位的监护人受到更严厉制裁的可能性比拥有本科学历或更高学历的监护人低0.28倍(p < 0.01)。针对监护人注册、许可、认证和质量;其他职业的许可和监管;研究的局限性;以及进一步研究的必要性,对研究结果进行了讨论。