Viciana J, Cervelló E M, Ramírez-Lechuga J
Department of Physical Education, University of Granada (Spain), Ctra. Alfacar s/n, 18011, España.
Percept Mot Skills. 2007 Aug;105(1):67-82. doi: 10.2466/pms.105.1.67-82.
This study examined the effect of different types of feedback on goal orientation, perception of motivational climate, satisfaction, and boredom in physical education (PE) classes, pupils' preferences for challenging versus easy tasks, pupils' attitudes towards PE lessons, and perception of gymnastic ability. 95 subjects in three treatment conditions (positive feedback, negative feedback, and both feedback types) participated in 14 lessons and completed pre- and postintervention measures. Results showed that subjects in the positive feedback group had significantly higher scores on learning-oriented motivational climate and enjoyment than the subjects of the negative feedback group. The negative feedback group reported higher scores on performance-oriented motivational climate than the positive feedback group. Results also showed that subjects in the group receiving both types of feedback had lower scores on learning-oriented motivational climate, higher scores on enjoyment than the negative feedback group, and lower scores on boredom than the positive feedback group. The effects of feedback on physical education students' motivation are discussed.
本研究考察了不同类型的反馈对体育课中目标定向、动机氛围感知、满意度和厌烦情绪的影响,以及学生对具有挑战性任务与简单任务的偏好、学生对体育课的态度和体操能力感知。95名处于三种处理条件(积极反馈、消极反馈以及两种反馈类型)下的受试者参加了14节课程,并完成了干预前后的测量。结果显示,积极反馈组受试者在以学习为导向的动机氛围和愉悦感方面的得分显著高于消极反馈组受试者。消极反馈组在以成绩为导向的动机氛围方面的得分高于积极反馈组。结果还表明,接受两种反馈的组中的受试者在以学习为导向的动机氛围方面得分较低,在愉悦感方面得分高于消极反馈组,在厌烦情绪方面得分低于积极反馈组。文中讨论了反馈对体育学生动机的影响。