Bongers Frans J M, Deunk Linelle E N, Schellevis Francois G, van den Hoogen Henk J M, van der Zee Jouke, van den Bosch Wil J H M
Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research NIVEL, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
BMC Public Health. 2007 Oct 25;7:305. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-7-305.
When comparing health differences of groups with equal socioeconomic status (SES) over time, the sociodemographic composition of such a SES group is considered to be constant. However, when the periods are sufficiently spaced in time, sociodemographic changes may have occurred. The aim of this study is to examine in which respects the sociodemographic composition of lowest SES group changed between 1987 and 2001.
Our data were derived from the first and second Dutch National Survey of General Practice conducted in 1987 and 2001. In 1987 sociodemographic data from all listed patients (N = 334,007) were obtained by filling out a registration form at the practice (response 78.3%, 261,691 persons), in 2001 these data from all listed patients (385,461) were obtained by postal survey (response 76.9%, 296,243 persons). Participants were primarily classified according to their occupation into three SES groups: lowest, middle and highest.
In comparison with 1987, the lowest SES group decreased in relative size from 34.9% to 29.5%. Within this smaller SES group, the relative contribution of persons with a higher education more than doubled for females and doubled for males. This indicates that the relation between educational level and occupation was less firmly anchored in 2001 than in 1987. The relative proportion of some disadvantaged groups (divorced, unemployed) increased in the lowest SES group, but the size of this effect was smaller than the increase from higher education. Young people (0-24 years) were proportionally less often represented in the lowest SES group. Non-Western immigrants contributed in 2001 proportionally less to the lowest SES group than in 1987, because of an intergenerational upward mobility of the second generation.
On balance, the changes in the composition did not result in an accumulation of disadvantaged groups in the lowest SES group. On the contrary, the influx of people with higher educational qualifications between 1987 and 2001 could result in better health outcomes and health perspectives of the lowest SES group.
在比较具有同等社会经济地位(SES)的群体随时间变化的健康差异时,这样一个SES群体的社会人口构成被认为是不变的。然而,当不同时期在时间上间隔足够长时,社会人口结构可能已经发生了变化。本研究的目的是调查1987年至2001年间最低SES群体的社会人口构成在哪些方面发生了变化。
我们的数据来自于1987年和2001年进行的第一次和第二次荷兰全科医学全国调查。1987年,通过在诊所填写登记表获取了所有登记患者(N = 334,007)的社会人口数据(回复率78.3%,261,691人),2001年,通过邮政调查获取了所有登记患者(385,461人)的这些数据(回复率76.9%,296,243人)。参与者主要根据其职业被分为三个SES组:最低、中等和最高。
与1987年相比,最低SES组的相对规模从34.9%降至29.5%。在这个规模变小的SES组中,受过高等教育的女性的相对贡献增加了一倍多,男性则增加了一倍。这表明2001年教育水平与职业之间的关系不如1987年那样紧密。一些弱势群体(离婚者、失业者)在最低SES组中的相对比例有所增加,但这种影响的规模小于受过高等教育者的增加幅度。年轻人(0 - 24岁)在最低SES组中的比例相对较低。由于第二代的代际向上流动,2001年非西方移民在最低SES组中的比例相对低于1987年。
总体而言,构成的变化并没有导致弱势群体在最低SES组中的聚集。相反,1987年至2001年间受过高等教育者的流入可能会使最低SES组的健康结果和健康前景得到改善。