Smith Ashley Wilder, Dougall Angela Liegey, Posluszny Donna M, Somers Tamara J, Rubinstein Wendy S, Baum Andrew
Division of Cancer Prevention, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Psychooncology. 2008 Aug;17(8):767-73. doi: 10.1002/pon.1291.
This study investigated short- and long-term psychological outcomes associated with BRCA1/2 genetic testing in women with a personal or family history of breast cancer. Participants included 126 women considering genetic testing. Questionnaires were administered prior to testing, one week, three and six months after result disclosure. Results indicated no systematic effects of testing based on personal cancer history. Mutation carriers and women who elected not to be tested reported greater perceived risk and intrusive and avoidant thoughts at follow-up time points than did women who received negative (uninformative) or variant results. Mutation carriers reported more distress at the three-month follow-up but by six months the effects of test result on distress dissipated and groups were comparable. Cluster analyses identified two groups of individuals based on distress at baseline; these groups were used to predict psychological outcomes after testing. Distress remained constant in both groups: those who were high at baseline remained high and those who were low remained low. Test results did not moderate this effect. Results suggest that genetic testing for BRCA1/2 does not increase distress or have deleterious effects on quality of life over the long term. However, sub-groups of women may report more distress over time. These data indicate the need for more targeted counseling to individuals who report high levels of distress when considering genetic testing.
本研究调查了有个人或家族乳腺癌病史的女性进行BRCA1/2基因检测所带来的短期和长期心理影响。研究对象包括126名考虑进行基因检测的女性。在检测前、结果披露后一周、三个月和六个月分别发放问卷。结果表明,基于个人癌症病史的检测没有系统性影响。与收到阴性(无信息价值)或变异结果的女性相比,突变携带者和选择不进行检测的女性在随访时间点报告的感知风险、侵入性和回避性想法更多。突变携带者在三个月随访时报告了更多的困扰,但到六个月时,检测结果对困扰的影响消失,各群体之间相当。聚类分析根据基线时的困扰程度确定了两组个体;这些组被用来预测检测后的心理结果。两组的困扰程度保持不变:基线时高的那些人仍然高,基线时低的那些人仍然低。检测结果并未缓和这种影响。结果表明,BRCA1/2基因检测不会长期增加困扰或对生活质量产生有害影响。然而,随着时间的推移,部分女性群体可能会报告更多困扰。这些数据表明,对于在考虑基因检测时报告高度困扰的个体,需要进行更有针对性的咨询。