Beltrán-Mateos Luis D, Santa Cruz-Ruiz Santiago, Coscarón-Bernabé Enrique, Solana-Sorribas Juan, Gil-Melcón María, Batuecas-Caletrío Angel
Servicio de Otorrinolaringología, Hospital Virgen de la Concha, Zamora [corrected] España.
Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2007 Nov;58(9):393-400.
The authors attempt to expand knowledge about a subjective balance disorder they have called phobic orthostatic insecurity, a condition representing the second cause of medical visits (22.3 %) to their ENT and neuro-otology clinic, and attempt to identify relationships with similar conditions described in psychiatry (agoraphobia, somatoform vertigo, and space-phobia) and in neurology (phobic postural vertigo). They also propose a simple diagnostic method and present their therapies and results.
A total of 151 patients with an indefinite symptomatology of "dizziness" "vertigo" or "insecurity" were evaluated (from 1999 to 2005) by means of a full medical history and an appropriate neurological examination, pharmacological treatments with anxiolytics-antidepressives, a measurement of the degree of depression with the Beck test (a kind of psychiatric benchmark) and with a specific standardized test.
Three symptoms and one exploratory condition, among others, were found in all 151 patients studied; these constitute the four bases for a positive diagnosis. This is confirmed if the treatment achieves total remission (this occurred in 69.53 % of all patients) or a sub-total remission (24.49 %), according to valuation scale for insecurity in all situations.
The statistical analysis showed a symptomatic concordance within the group analyzed, a syndromic equivalence between patients and satisfactory results with the antidepressive treatments (94 %), thus confirming the diagnostic and aetiopathogenic hypotheses for the disorder and, later, providing a logical method for diagnosis. The authors propose to assimilate this diagnostic protocol (and therapeutic when no specialist psychotherapy teams are available) to most of the psychogenic insecurity syndromes described.
作者试图拓展对一种他们称为恐旷性直立性不安的主观平衡障碍的认识,该病症是其耳鼻喉科和神经耳科学门诊就医的第二大原因(占22.3%),并试图确定与精神病学中描述的类似病症(广场恐惧症、躯体形式眩晕和空间恐惧症)以及神经病学中(恐旷性姿势性眩晕)的关系。他们还提出了一种简单的诊断方法,并展示了他们的治疗方法和结果。
从1999年至2005年,对总共151例有“头晕”“眩晕”或“不安”等不确定症状的患者进行了全面病史评估和适当的神经学检查、使用抗焦虑 - 抗抑郁药物进行药物治疗、用贝克测试(一种精神病学基准)和特定标准化测试来测量抑郁程度。
在所有研究的151例患者中发现了三种症状和一种探索性情况等;这些构成了阳性诊断的四个依据。根据所有情况下不安的评估量表,如果治疗实现完全缓解(所有患者中有69.53%出现这种情况)或部分缓解(24.49%),则可确认诊断。
统计分析显示在分析的组内存在症状一致性,患者之间存在综合征等效性,且抗抑郁治疗效果令人满意(94%),从而证实了该病症的诊断和病因假设,随后提供了一种合理的诊断方法。作者建议将这种诊断方案(在没有专业心理治疗团队时也包括治疗方法)应用于所描述的大多数心因性不安综合征。