Mayes Russell W, Jackson-Menaldi Cristina, Dejonckere Philippe H, Moyer Cheryl A, Rubin Adam D
POH Medical Center, Pontiac, MI, USA.
J Voice. 2008 Nov;22(6):756-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2007.03.005. Epub 2007 Nov 26.
We evaluate a group of patients who have mobile vocal folds, but have flexible laryngeal examinations suspicious for mild vocal fold paresis. The purpose of this retrospective study is to evaluate if electroglottography (EGG) can predict the probability of having an abnormal laryngeal electromyography (LEMG). Charts of patients evaluated and suspected of having mild vocal fold paresis between August 1, 2004 and March 30, 2006 were reviewed. We compared average EGG contact quotients (CQs), average absolute difference of recorded CQ from normal (|CQ-50%|), and EGG waveforms between patients with normal and abnormal LEMG. Waveforms were evaluated in blinded fashion. Statistical analysis was performed using chi square and t test analyses. One hundred and sixteen patients received both flexible laryngoscopy and LEMG as part of their evaluation. Forty-eight patients (41%) had confirmed paresis by LEMG and 68 patients (59%) had normal LEMGs. Only 9.1% of patients with a normal EGG waveform had an abnormal LEMG. In contrast, 40.4% of patients with an abnormal EGG waveform had abnormal LEMGs. The negative predictive value of a normal EGG waveform for an abnormal LEMG was 90.9%. No significant differences were identified between patients with normal versus abnormal LEMG in terms of average CQ (47.8% vs 46.4%) or |CQ-50%| (6.2 vs 5.6). Patients with a normal EGG waveform are unlikely to have an abnormal LEMG.
我们评估了一组声带可活动,但喉镜检查结果提示可能存在轻度声带麻痹的患者。这项回顾性研究的目的是评估电声门图(EGG)能否预测喉肌电图(LEMG)异常的可能性。我们回顾了2004年8月1日至2006年3月30日期间接受评估且疑似患有轻度声带麻痹患者的病历。我们比较了LEMG正常和异常患者的平均EGG接触商(CQs)、记录的CQ与正常水平的平均绝对差值(|CQ - 50%|)以及EGG波形。波形评估采用盲法。使用卡方检验和t检验进行统计分析。116例患者接受了纤维喉镜检查和LEMG检查作为评估的一部分。48例患者(41%)经LEMG证实存在麻痹,68例患者(59%)LEMG正常。EGG波形正常的患者中只有9.1%的LEMG异常。相比之下,EGG波形异常的患者中有40.4%的LEMG异常。EGG波形正常对LEMG异常的阴性预测值为90.9%。LEMG正常与异常的患者在平均CQ(47.8%对46.4%)或|CQ - 50%|(6.2对5.6)方面未发现显著差异。EGG波形正常的患者不太可能出现LEMG异常。