Harrison W N, Lancashire R J, Marshall T P
Department of Public Health and Epidemiology, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
J Hum Hypertens. 2008 Mar;22(3):163-7. doi: 10.1038/sj.jhh.1002312. Epub 2007 Nov 29.
This study aims to identify the extent of terminal digit bias in routinely recorded blood pressures (BP) across a number of different general practices and report on changes in terminal digit bias over a 10-year period. It also explores the effect this may have had on the mean recorded BP in this population. BP records were taken from The Health Improvement Network database containing anonymized patient records from information entered by UK general practices in the financial years 1996-1997 to 2005-2006. The proportion of measurements ending in zero and the mean BP readings were calculated for each practice and for each year of data.Over this 10-year period the percentage of systolic BPs with zero terminal digits fell from 71.2 to 36.7% and mean recorded BP fell from 152.3 to 145.3 mm Hg. Correcting the BPs to remove terminal digit bias indicates a 2-3 mm Hg underestimation of the mean population systolic BP over this period. The between-practice variation in the percentage of zero terminal digit readings increased from 3.5 to 6.5 s.d. Although it is welcome to see a reduction in terminal digit bias, it is worrying to see the increase in variation between practices. There is evidence that terminal digit bias may lead to potential misclassification and inappropriate treatment of hypertensive patients. The increase in variation observed may therefore lead to an increased variation in the quality of care given to patients.
本研究旨在确定在多个不同的全科医疗中常规记录的血压(BP)中末位数字偏好的程度,并报告10年间末位数字偏好的变化情况。它还探讨了这可能对该人群记录的平均血压产生的影响。血压记录取自健康改善网络数据库,该数据库包含英国全科医疗在1996 - 1997财年至2005 - 2006财年输入的匿名患者记录。计算了每个医疗机构以及每年数据中末位为零的测量比例和平均血压读数。在这10年期间,收缩压末位数字为零的百分比从71.2%降至36.7%,记录的平均血压从152.3毫米汞柱降至145.3毫米汞柱。校正血压以消除末位数字偏好表明在此期间人群平均收缩压被低估了2 - 3毫米汞柱。末位数字为零的读数百分比在不同医疗机构之间的差异从3.5标准差增加到6.5标准差。虽然末位数字偏好的减少是值得欢迎的,但不同医疗机构之间差异的增加令人担忧。有证据表明末位数字偏好可能导致高血压患者的潜在错误分类和不适当治疗。因此,观察到的差异增加可能导致给予患者的护理质量差异加大。