East Christine E, Colditz Paul B
From the Perinatal Research Centre, The University of Queensland, Royal Brisbane and Women's Hospital, Brisbane, Australia.
Anesth Analg. 2007 Dec;105(6 Suppl):S59-S65. doi: 10.1213/01.ane.0000268493.90073.f3.
Fetal monitoring during labor aims to identify fetal problems which, if uncorrected, may result in morbidity or death. A nonreassuring or abnormal fetal heart rate trace by cardiotocography (CTG) does not necessarily equate with fetal hypoxia and/or acidosis. However, in the absence of more objective data, the use of CTG often results in variable, but inappropriately high, operative delivery rates (forceps, vacuum, or cesarean delivery) for nonreassuring fetal status in many hospitals. The addition of fetal pulse oximetry (FPO) has the potential to improve the assessment of fetal well-being during labor. In this review we consider several aspects of FPO. Several factors, such as sensor to skin contact, uterine contractions, fetal hair, and caput succedaneum, influence the performance and use of FPO. Issues such as clinicians' perspectives of FPO sensor placement, maternal perspectives of FPO during labor, and an economic analysis have all favored FPO. Several randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of FPO reported a reduction in cesarean delivery for nonreassuring fetal status when FPO was added to conventional CTG monitoring, with no difference in overall cesarean delivery rates. One large RCT reported no difference in mode of birth for any indication. Several issues relevant to the future of FPO have been addressed by these RCTs, the major issue being that it makes no difference to cesarean rates. It may be argued that FPO has a valid clinical use in monitoring the fetus with congenital heart block. Additionally, in situations of nonreassuring fetal status and dystocia, FPO may provide the necessary reassurance until adequate resources for cesarean delivery are available.
分娩期间的胎儿监护旨在识别那些若不纠正可能导致发病或死亡的胎儿问题。通过胎心监护(CTG)得出的令人不安或异常的胎心率曲线不一定等同于胎儿缺氧和/或酸中毒。然而,在缺乏更客观数据的情况下,在许多医院,使用CTG常常导致因胎儿状况令人不安而进行的手术分娩率(产钳、真空吸引或剖宫产)出现变化,但却过高且不合理。增加胎儿脉搏血氧饱和度测定(FPO)有可能改善分娩期间对胎儿健康状况的评估。在这篇综述中,我们考虑了FPO的几个方面。几个因素,如传感器与皮肤的接触、子宫收缩、胎儿毛发和头皮水肿,会影响FPO的性能和使用。诸如临床医生对FPO传感器放置的看法、产妇在分娩期间对FPO的看法以及经济分析等问题都支持FPO。几项FPO的随机对照试验(RCT)报告称,在传统CTG监测中加入FPO后,因胎儿状况令人不安而进行剖宫产的比例有所降低,而总体剖宫产率没有差异。一项大型RCT报告称,任何指征下的分娩方式都没有差异。这些RCT已经探讨了与FPO未来相关的几个问题,主要问题是它对剖宫产率没有影响。可以认为FPO在监测患有先天性心脏传导阻滞的胎儿方面具有有效的临床用途。此外,在胎儿状况令人不安和难产的情况下,FPO可能会提供必要的安心保障,直到有足够的资源进行剖宫产。